Menu toggle

911 turbo vs boxster S

ianmac

New member
Hi Folks i am lucky enough to own a Boxster S but this week was invited to drive the new 911 turbo by my local OPC, Two things, the 911 Turbo is awesome, ive always wanted to drive the legend that is the 911 turbo BUT was worried that after driving it my own Boxster S would feel dull BUT it didn't at all, truth is it only confirmed what ive always said, "Porsche , there is NO substitute!" what ever Porsche you have you are blessed with the best......:)
 
Obviously there is a lot of personal preference here, but I do agree with you. My first Porsche in 2006, was a new 911 cab which we were very careful with! Also thrashed several different 911s on the track, but never in a Boxster as none of the track schools have them? It never even occurred to me to even try the Boxster until two years later when I had a test drive. At that point I felt that the Boxster had better handling, required less concentration to drive, was less ostentatious, more practical for carrying stuff and a lot of fun. I realised why it had been designed to replace the 911. So I sold the 911 privately and bought a six month old Boxster S for 60% of the money and have never stopped enjoying myself. It takes opinions to make a horse race, but thats mine.
 
After 5 911's between 1978 - 1990 when I purchased a brand new delivery miles 911 Speedster I thought I would never ever own anything but a 911 again .... Fast forward to 1997 and I bought my first 986 whilst still keeping the garage queen Speedster.  By 2003 and Boxster number 3 a 986 S the thrill of the 911 had finally been toppled by the stunning perfectly balanced mid engined sports car [8D]   Currently on Boxster number 5 a 987 S which has been nothing but an absolute sporting joy to drive every single mile to date and despite occassionally having an opportunity every so often to drive various 997's I can't ever see myself leaving the mid-engined Porsche's unless I needed a 2+2 of course Whilst both the 911 & Boxster are always the class leaders in there specific catergories I think £ for £ the Boxster has to be the best value Porsche of all times and one of the most fun to drive.  Long may it run and can't wait to see the next evolution into a 988 probably looking pretty much as attached digi [;)]    
211DE3F7BD654BECB576DBFF61DBCF6D.jpg
 
A few years ago I went to a Porsche driving day at Castle Combe. There was about a dozen Porsches (various Boxters and 911s, but no Turbo or GT3) and existing customers and propective buyers could drive any car for 5 or 6 laps at a time, with a Porsche driving consultant in the px seat. I well recall how many people loved the Boxster 'S'. But one guy got out looking a bit glum. I asked him if he didn't like it? "No", he said, "I loved it. But I'm gutted. I've just spent over twice the price on a new Turbo, for half the fun".
 
ORIGINAL: ianmac Hi Folks i am lucky enough to own a Boxster S but this week was invited to drive the new 911 turbo by my local OPC, Two things, the 911 Turbo is awesome, ive always wanted to drive the legend that is the 911 turbo BUT was worried that after driving it my own Boxster S would feel dull BUT it didn't at all, truth is it only confirmed what ive always said, "Porsche , there is NO substitute!" what ever Porsche you have you are blessed with the best......:)
Another glowing report on why own a Boxster model of your choice [ Simple omission is part of the secret. The Spyder comes standard with 2.6 gal. less fuel capacity, no radio or air conditioning (they can be ordered as options) and inner door handles that are simple fabric loops. But other pieces are lighter as well: The doors are aluminum skinned, side windows are shorter, the unique 10-spoke alloy wheels are lighter and the comfortable (but not rake-adjustable) sport bucket seats alone trim 26 lb. from the car. Besides improving the power-to-weight ratio to 8.6 lb./bhp—thus making the unoptioned 2810-lb. Spyder the lightest car in the entire Porsche range—all this trimming lowers the car’s center of gravity by almost an inch, aided by a 0.79-in. drop in ride height. This has been accomplished with a new sport suspension setup that uses shorter, stiffer springs, uprated anti-roll bars and slightly harder shock absorber settings. The new wheels also have a wider offset for a small gain in track, and new, lower-pressure tires help mitigate the stiffer suspension and improve ride quality. Pushing this lighter, lower car down the road is the torquey and glassy-smooth 3.4-liter engine, which has gained its 10 extra horsepower mostly through its new direct-injection fuel system, an “on demand” oil pump that doesn’t pressurize the system more than necessary and intake tract flaps that regulate resonance for the current engine speed. So can you feel all these changes when you drive? Yes. Your first trip down a winding road with the new Spyder brings a renewed acquaintance with the term “euphoric rush.” The engine makes power and torque everywhere and accelerates to its 7400-rpm redline in a silky, seamless surge, with spot-on throttle response. The car feels immediately quicker and more willing than any Boxster we’ve driven. And is—with the exception of the PDK-equipped Boxster S we tested in our “Sunshine Special” feature (July 2009), whose superhumanly quick-shifting double-clutch gearbox produced 0–60 and quarter-mile times 0.3 and 0.2 seconds more fleet, respectively, than the Spyder’s. While the PDK 7-speed is a Spyder option, we found our test car’s old-school 6-speed manual a pleasure to use—short throws and precise engagement—even if it does mean surrendering those precious tenths. Brakes—typical for Porsche—are powerful and easily modulated. The new sport suspension is still quite civilized and compliant over rough roads, though the full Sport setting feels best on smoother pavement—or the racetrack. Steering is sharp but natural, with a quick transition into corners, followed by mild understeer. It’s a very high-grip car (1.02g on the skidpad, versus 0.98g for that Boxster S) that carries momentum effortlessly, and you have to disengage the PSM (Porsche Stability Management) if you want things slidey and loose. Even then, there’s a reassuringly high threshold. This car just grips and goes, fluidly following the road surface. This is also evident in the slalom, where the more svelte Spyder sliced through the cones at 74.6 mph, 2.2 mph quicker than the standard Boxster S. Overall, the Spyder is a delight to drive, and a reminder that, for pure balance, power, luggage space (two reasonably large trunks), daily practicality and driving pleasure, the Boxster is pretty much in a class by itself. And driving this particular version created a bad case of “I gotta get me one of these!” among several of our staff, although most admitted the standard S model—with its effortless cabriolet top—would do just fine. Which brings up an interesting question: Will the modern Boxster fan be seduced by a $61,200 car with a fiddly top and optional radio and air conditioning? We suspect one of two things will happen. Buyers will order a Spyder and then add some of that weight back with a few comfort options—and still find themselves with likely the quickest (with PDK) and best-handling Boxster ever—or they’ll be drawn into the showroom and then settle for the slightly more civilized standard Boxster or S model. Hard to go wrong, either way. Though the true purist may happily leave the car just as it is.
 
Interesting reading! I just don't see the comparison of a 911 and Boxster! Ok, I have never owned a Boxster but have driven a few. A believe a Cayman is a better option than the Boxster but none compare with a 911! I will get stick, I am sure but once a 911 man, always a 911 man!!
 
Interestingly enough the profit margin on Boxsters is miniscule compared to 911. That's why Porsche are introducing a 4 cyl turbo "baby" boxster so that they can push the Boxster price upwards. So £ for £ you are getting better value for money from a Boxster one must conclude. For my view I have always hankered after a 911. However I test drove a new 997s and to be frank there was not the huge step change in fun/ driver enjoyment I had expected. Sure the acceleration was outstanding and everything was at higher speeds. But I did not like the front bobbing up and down like my old Beetle and my partner could not believe how much more expensive it was without much else to offer above the Boxster. I still want one to live with (997) and see if I really would miss the Boxster - but too scared to part with Boxster in case I regret it as 997 test drive was not convincing as expected.
 
Thanks for your thoughts folks, it is interesting to hear other peoples thoughts, the test drive the other day was very interesting for many reasons, re circleace,s question about the Cayman being perhaps a better option well I must say I didn't consider it as my car HAD to be a soft top. Porsche there is no substitute
 
I had a Boxsters S 986 and loved it. Roof down and blasting along in the summer was great, unfortunately her indoors didn't like the roof down (hair getting blown etc) and one weekend I was lucky to get a Cayman S as a loan car when the Boxster went in for a roof clean and a valet. Convinced me that was the solution, and that is where I ended up a year ago with a Cayman S. It hasn't got the open air motoring pleasure of the Boxster but as that was in reality in short supply, the Cayman is a very good alternative. It is an 06 model and certainly feels much quicker than my 03 Boxster and doesn't suffer from the sweeky hood which needed regular cleaning of the rubber trim and lubrication. Pays your money and makes your choice. I'll not bitch about the Boxster, I loved it, as I do the Cayman. I still have a fancy for a nice 911 though, but why, when the Cayman is so good?
 
[/quote]
I still have a fancy for a nice 911 though, but why, when the Cayman is so good?
Try a GT3 and you will know why....[;)] But has already been said, there really is no substitute.... g
 
Went from a Boxster 987S straight to the 997 Turbo as the 997 just didn't do it for me. If Porsche did not make a Turbo I would be in a Boxster all day long [:D] I agree the Boxster is the best value Porsche you can buy, stunning car, appears only to be rated by the motoring press and punter's who own them for some strange reason. [8D]
 

Posts made and opinions expressed are those of the individual forum members

Use of the Forum is subject to the Terms and Conditions

Disclaimer

The opinions expressed on this site are not necessarily those of the Club, who shall have no liability in respect of them or the accuracy of the content. The Club assumes no responsibility for any effects arising from errors or omissions.

Porsche Club Great Britain gives no warranties, guarantees or assurances and makes no representations or recommendations regarding any goods or services advertised on this site. It is the responsibility of visitors to satisfy themselves that goods and/or services supplied by any advertiser are bona fide and in no instance can the Porsche Club Great Britain be held responsible.

When responding to advertisements please ensure that you satisfy yourself of any applicable call charges on numbers not prefixed by usual "landline" STD Codes. Information can be obtained from the operator or the white pages. Before giving out ANY information regarding cars, or any other items for sale, please satisfy yourself that any potential purchaser is bona fide.

Directors of the Board of Porsche Club GB, Club Office Staff, Register Secretaries and Regional Organisers are often requested by Club members to provide information on matters connected with their cars and other matters referred to in the Club Rules. Such information, advice and assistance provided by such persons is given in good faith and is based on the personal experience and knowledge of the individual concerned.

Neither Porsche Club GB, nor any of the aforementioned, shall be under any liability in respect of any such information, advice or assistance given to members. Members are advised to consult qualified specialists for information, advice and assistance on matters connected with their cars at all times.

Back
Top