Hi, I have used Warranty Direct for my previous Mini Cooper S, and my Boxster 3.2 S. I too was worried about Warranty companies reputations and whether they would pay out, from what I could find they seemed pretty good. I have not had anything go wrong (touch wood...) on the Boxster as yet, but my previous mini did have issues and I claimed well over the yearly premium. Key points with WD is that they cover cars up to 120k miles, 10 years old. And seem reasonable in their claims dept. I checked if things like IMS etc on the Boxster are covered and their documents confirm this . Their weasel words are not too onerous . They also importantly cover wear and tear, once a car gets to 60k, they then start reducing the percentage of parts costs dowen to 50% at 120k. However labour (and I have main dealer rates cover) is 100% even at 120k . Of course other people may have had issues with them, , but I have stuck with them and signed up to a 3 year warranty with discount on my Boxster as I plan to keep her for some time. I also looked at Warranty Wise, who also look like they cover wear and tear too.... I will also be covering my current mini with them too. Good luck. Cheers Chris