First of all, excuse me for my poor english (I'm french...).
When I ordered my BBS Racing wheels (to fit on my 993 RS CS) directly from BBS Motorsport, I was told from the BBS commercial:
* the aly are as light as the mag
* in Germany, the mag do never get the TÃœV homologation, that meens the germans are not allowed to drive on open road with them. The reason is the risk of crack, which seems to be very high. The racing teams which used them let them x-ray very often.
* the aly get the TÃœV homologation.
So far, I am very satisfy with the aly. But it's true that the outer rims needs to be polished very often. I didn't anodized them, because BBS couldn't tell me which type of aluminium they use. And if the aluminium is not suitable to this process, the result can be very awfull (brown instead of silver). So was a little afraid about the final result.
In the mean time, I've heard that some people in France had problems with the cracking of the outer/inner rim!!! So need some visual check time to time.