Menu toggle

Carrera or RS

Guest

New member
If you did'nt need back seats and your car was not used daily just weekends etc would any of you 964 owners have a 964 RS instead, I know it sounds a silly question but I have the option shortly to buy a mint RS but could have a mint carrera 2 for half the price.What I am trying to work out does the RS give twice the fun, or is a well sorted carrera 2 just as enjoyable and the basis of your kind replies is just on pure ownership enjoyment and nothing to do with depreciation, purchase price or investment potential etc,

regards

Dick
 
Before entering the Temple of the Leichtbau I owned a C2 in Rubystone with full track set up LHD great car..........The RS is just very different that's all I can say....[;)]

FAADF6578D7B4DA9BEA5B98DF05808C0.jpg
 
First of all I should start by saying I've never driven an RS. However surely the answer to this depends on how big your wallet is. The RS sounds fantastic but they are just so much more expensive than a standard Carrera. If I had that amount of cash to spend, I'd be tempted to buy a decent Carrera and ask someone like Ninemeister to work their magic on it. You could end up with one hell of a quick car and you'd have a big pile of change left over. Also depends on how you are going to use the car (trackdays etc) and your own ability as a driver to get the best out of it.
Nice problem to have though!
 
Just read your question properly! So money doesn't come into it: in that case its simply down to which car is best suited to the use to which you are going to put it and if its sheer entertainment and driver satisfaction, then it would have to be an RS.
 
I have also owned both and they are both completely different machines. That happen to share a layout and some components. If you want an "all rounder" go for the C2 but you will always be wishing / thinking you could buy an RS, that's what I did and ended up buying one. I strongly advise you drive both and see which you prefer.
 
If you like to take it on track get an RS.

If you very seldom (or never) venture on track go for a C2.

You will not get the full benefit of an RS on public roads - Lightened flywheel is prone to stalling in heavy traffic / at parking speeds and the stiffer suspension makes for bumpy (slower) progress on B roads.
Not to say the RS is rubbish on the road - just not as easy as a regular C2.

Of course the moment you take an RS on track you will think it was worth every penny more you spent....
 
ORIGINAL: sbloxxy

First of all I should start by saying I've never driven an RS. However surely the answer to this depends on how big your wallet is. The RS sounds fantastic but they are just so much more expensive than a standard Carrera. If I had that amount of cash to spend, I'd be tempted to buy a decent Carrera and ask someone like Ninemeister to work their magic on it. You could end up with one hell of a quick car and you'd have a big pile of change left over. Also depends on how you are going to use the car (trackdays etc) and your own ability as a driver to get the best out of it.
Nice problem to have though!

I would agree if I had that option to !

Mark
 
My C2 is for sale in the members forum with links to pistonheads and the garage I have it at on a commission basis.

Thanks

Mark
 
ORIGINAL: dick

If you did'nt need back seats and your car was not used daily just weekends etc would any of you 964 owners have a 964 RS instead, I know it sounds a silly question but I have the option shortly to buy a mint RS but could have a mint carrera 2 for half the price.What I am trying to work out does the RS give twice the fun, or is a well sorted carrera 2 just as enjoyable and the basis of your kind replies is just on pure ownership enjoyment and nothing to do with depreciation, purchase price or investment potential etc,

regards

Dick

Yes, especially if you're in to track days. I bought a C2 about 4 years ago, and in hindsight should have stretched a bit to get an RS instead. Having said that, the C2 is a lot of fun even on track (just upgrade the suspension to bilsteins/H+R), and it would have to be a pretty good RS condition-wise to tempt me away from it now.
 
Dick

If I had my way again, I'd have waited and found an RS. I love my C4 but for what I want it for an RS would've been a better buy.
If you want a car that's great on track, and you want touse on track and not be a garage queen and shouldn't loose any money (and may even gain) the RS is the one to go for.
If you want to toddle around the lanes in relative comfort, go for a non RS 964 and spec up to your desire.

There are a lot of RS replicas around, some done brilliantly but they will never be an original RS.

Just my two pence worth.

Rob

ps - and the RS your looking at is a great car.

 
Just spent a track day at Croft: I hereby withdraw my previous comments about a Carrera 2/4 being nearly as good! There were a few RS Porsches there and apart from looking awesome, they were just so quick. I followed a couple round and their suspension set up meant they could put the power down where I simply could not - I'd have been off the track.
 
ORIGINAL: sbloxxy

Just spent a track day at Croft: I hereby withdraw my previous comments about a Carrera 2/4 being nearly as good! There were a few RS Porsches there and apart from looking awesome, they were just so quick. I followed a couple round and their suspension set up meant they could put the power down where I simply could not - I'd have been off the track.

There was a few of us going quite quickly weren't there[;)]

It's simple Dick - C2 or C4 for road use, RS for the track, you just have to work out what you are REALLY going to use the car for.
 
Jamie-that's a cracker-I hope you are not dissatisfied with the RS :)

Where did you get the wheels done ?

and the front splitter ?
 
ORIGINAL: Jeff Forsyth

It would be interesting to compare the same RS driver in a really well set-up RS like C2 V a standard RS.

Would be interesting to see what the same driver could do in all versions.
I'd be willing to let a sensible RS driver (Ollie/Jason/Mel/Simon and a few others) drive my C4 (slight track set up) angainst a C2 (RS like) and original RS.

Rob
 
It's an interesting debate! My words of wisdom may be a bit different from others. Now, these are just my views and may be at odds with others but I know I am right [;)][:D]

The first thing is that, IMO, don't get a C2 and modify it unless you are happy to effectively throw the money away. I have seen some wonderful cars built but they are rarely worth more than a standard car and sometimes less. However, done sensibly, you can end up with a car that is a good comprimise between a C2 and an RS.

The next issue is the whole business of the ride quality of an RS on UK roads. Let's get one thing straight. It is firm! It is probably too firm for all but a handful of enthusists who want something very specific from their cars. But make no mistake. It is a total myth that it is too firm. I can name modern cars which are as firm or even worse that don't have the same stigma.Is it too firm for UK "B" roads? For many, yes, but I cannot agree.

For many, the RS is not an everyday car but as a weekend toy, for people who are looking for a certain something, there is nothing that beats it. Effectively, you are buying a road legal road car. The noises and sensations are those of a track car. If you want to go for a nice spirited drive in the country with your wife, get the C2. If you want to make sure she doesn't want to come with, get the RS (now where is the tongue in cheek smiley!).

Once you reach the track, the cars are chalk and cheese. Only an RS will do!

So, you need to decide what you really want and the best way is to try both. Then you will know which you want.
 
ORIGINAL: sbloxxy

First of all I should start by saying I've never driven an RS. However surely the answer to this depends on how big your wallet is. The RS sounds fantastic but they are just so much more expensive than a standard Carrera. If I had that amount of cash to spend, I'd be tempted to buy a decent Carrera and ask someone like Ninemeister to work their magic on it. You could end up with one hell of a quick car and you'd have a big pile of change left over. Also depends on how you are going to use the car (trackdays etc) and your own ability as a driver to get the best out of it.
Nice problem to have though!

Drive one.....[;)]
 

Posts made and opinions expressed are those of the individual forum members

Use of the Forum is subject to the Terms and Conditions

Disclaimer

The opinions expressed on this site are not necessarily those of the Club, who shall have no liability in respect of them or the accuracy of the content. The Club assumes no responsibility for any effects arising from errors or omissions.

Porsche Club Great Britain gives no warranties, guarantees or assurances and makes no representations or recommendations regarding any goods or services advertised on this site. It is the responsibility of visitors to satisfy themselves that goods and/or services supplied by any advertiser are bona fide and in no instance can the Porsche Club Great Britain be held responsible.

When responding to advertisements please ensure that you satisfy yourself of any applicable call charges on numbers not prefixed by usual "landline" STD Codes. Information can be obtained from the operator or the white pages. Before giving out ANY information regarding cars, or any other items for sale, please satisfy yourself that any potential purchaser is bona fide.

Directors of the Board of Porsche Club GB, Club Office Staff, Register Secretaries and Regional Organisers are often requested by Club members to provide information on matters connected with their cars and other matters referred to in the Club Rules. Such information, advice and assistance provided by such persons is given in good faith and is based on the personal experience and knowledge of the individual concerned.

Neither Porsche Club GB, nor any of the aforementioned, shall be under any liability in respect of any such information, advice or assistance given to members. Members are advised to consult qualified specialists for information, advice and assistance on matters connected with their cars at all times.

Back
Top