Menu toggle

Cayman S Has Serious Competition For The First Time Ever!

daro911

PCGB Member
Member
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Lotus Evora 3.5 V6 S First DriveTest date 28 October 2010

A supercharger has been added to the Evora's 3.5 V6 to boost power to 345bhp

What is it?
The Evora S is the car that Lotus believes is good enough to be priced above the Porsche Cayman, and only slightly beneath the basic 911 Carrera. Hence it costs £58,995 in 2+2 trim and goes on sale at the end of November.

In the simplest terms it's a more powerful, faster version of the already excellent base Evora, the extra go arriving courtesy of a supercharged version of that car's Toyota-sourced 3.5-litre V6. But in reality it is, according to Lotus, "the car we always wanted to build." In other words the version of the Evora we've all been waiting for.

The headline news concerns the more powerful supercharged engine, of course, which now develops a rousing 345bhp at 7000rpm and 295lb ft at 4000rpm "" enough muscle to send the 1437kg Evora S to 60mph in a claimed 4.6sec and to 172mph. But there have been improvements made throughout the rest of the car to further improve its dynamic behaviour "" and, of course, to justify its £10k premium.

The most significant of these concerns the six-speed manual transmission. This remains as before internally but now features an improved shift mechanism, a lower inertia clutch, new shift cables and a redesigned pedal box to reduce pedal effort. The suspension and steering have also been preened in line with the increased performance, though not, Lotus insists, at the expense of the base car's exquisite ride quality.

What's it like?
In a word, brilliant. As suggested, it still rides beautifully, gliding across pockmarked surfaces as if it's been touched by some Higher Being. It wouldn't be a Lotus were this not so. But what you really notice, of course, is what happens when you put your foot down "" because that's when the Evora S reveals its true self. The handling and steering seem to crystallise and become even sharper, even more responsive as a result of the extra torque that's available. After a day at the wheel of this car you realise that the Porsche Cayman is no longer quite so supreme.

In short, the supercharged Evora is one of those cars that, for whatever reason, manages to over-deliver on the sum of its parts on the road. It feels so much more than an Evora with an extra 70bhp.

Not only does it go way harder than before but it sounds, feels and IS hugely more invigorating to drive. The extra engine noise alone makes it seem like a completely different animal on the road. There are rasps and fizzes from the supercharger at low to middling revs that mingle perfectly with the deeper bass sound of the exhaust. As a combination it makes for a truly rousing soundtrack, one that provides just the right accompaniment to the increased performance. Which, by the way, is considerable.

Lotus may claim a 0-60mph time of 4.6sec and 172mph flat out, but between 4000-6000rpm it feels even faster than those numbers suggest. And, thank the lord, the gearchange "" though still not squeaky clean above 6000rpm "" is approximately 15,000 times better than before. It glides through the gate with a much more precise, mechanical feel, one that actually adds rather than detracts from the car's appeal.

Even the interior has been much improved, not on the design front but, more significantly, in terms of the way it's built. A few months ago Lotus poached some key people from Porsche's quality control department, by all accounts, and already they are making a difference. A fairly big difference if the test car is a typical example.

Should I buy one?
Can't see why not if you're in the market for a £60k mid-engined sports car and are only interested in driving the very best. Even amid the bubbling excitement of what's to come at Lotus, the Evora S is a stand out car right now, a stroke of rare genius.

And if you're wondering then the answer's yes; I'd have one over a Cayman any day.

Lotus Evora S
Price: £58,995; 0-60mph; 4.6sec (claimed); Top speed: 172mph (claimed); Economy:"¨ 27.7mpg (combined); CO2: 235g/km; Kerb weight: 1437kg; Engine layout: 3.5-litre V6, petrol, supercharged; Power: 345bhp at 7000rpm; Torque: 295lb ft at 4500rpm; Gearbox: 6-speed manual
 
£60k for a Lotus ? - having a larf ! I've have reservations spending £25k ona Lotus, never mind 60k.
 
ORIGINAL: Black80XSA £60k for a Lotus ? - having a larf ! I've have reservations spending £25k ona Lotus, never mind 60k.
I think you will find the game has moved on drastically since Colin's reign [;)]and now under some ex Ferrari men is about to shift up many gears Last week’s Lotus Elite news bombshell has turned out merely to be the beginning of an extraordinary Lotus product explosion which will, company bosses say, put six brand new Lotus models into the market by 2016, establish a new design style for all future models and bring an end to the company’s 15 years of accumulated losses. At today’s Paris motor show, Lotus has unveiled six full-size models models which, if successful, will move the company’s image and prices into Aston Martin, Ferrari and Porsche territory. “Our plan is to change Lotus from its present position as a niche sports car company to a builder of a range of premium sports cars”, says CEO Dany Bahar, architect of the company’s new five-year plan. A couple of the six new Lotus concepts are intended for production even sooner than the front-engined V8 Elite hybrid revealed as a styling model last week and proposed for 2014. The new cars, whose launch is being accompanied by developments costing many millions to Lotus’s factories, design facilities, test track and motorsport activities, and there is to be a new museum and heritage centre. The work, which has already started, will involve “fully funded” expenditure running to £770 million over the next decade. The models include a replacement for the Elise, an all-new Esprit, the Elite and a larger Eterne saloon based on it, a new Elan and even a new city car co-developed with parent firm Proton. New Esprit leads Lotus expansion Lotus Elan targets Porsche 911 Lotus Elite returns to rival Aston DB9 New Lotus Elise set for 2015 Lotus's new Eterne super-saloon Lotus's luxury new city car The whole project is being underwritten by Malaysian-based Proton, Lotus’s parent, which decided 18 months after a radical change of management (and management policy) that it had only two stark options with Lotus’s future: to hold an immediate fire-sale or develop the company to the extent of its potential. That was when the new Proton team began talking to Dany Bahar, then a sales and marketing chief at Ferrari in Maranello, and the plan took “maybe three months” to devise. The new Lotus models, which Bahar insists will employ the purist engineering principles of lightness and simplicity pioneered by the earliest Lotuses by the company’s founder, Colin Chapman, will take the company from annual production of around 2700 sub-£40,000 cars, to between 6000 and 7000 cars costing between £80,000 and £120,000. Even the Elise replacement, by the time it reaches production in 2015, will have an entry price approaching £40,000.
 
Have you sat in an Evora yet ? It certainly doesnt feel a 60 K car , true its got credentials and pedigree but its cramped compared to a cayman, has no practicality and would be less easy to live with day to day (boot space , availbility of service centres / spares etc). If you have 60 K and want the ultimate track day car with the ability to drive on the road , a 996 Gt3 would surely be a better bet ?
 
I too have been to have along hard look at the Evora, although I confess I have not driven it. It is too big, too wide and impractical compared to the Cayman. The build quality reminded me of the old Renault Alpine GTA (remember those?) which is neither a compliment nor an insult, just an observation that small firms like Alpine or Lotus simply do not have the wherewithall to build a car to the same standards as Porsche (let alone Audi, BMW, et al). If the Evora was the same price as the Cayman I'd consider it (just) and if it was priced below the Cayman I'd consider it seriously. But at the prices Lotus want, I wouldn't even give it a second thought, no matter how brilliantly it might drive.
 
hi John -- long time no see !! just spotted this thread and have to agree reluctantly that the Evora whilst a very attractive proposition as a drivers car, it just does not stack up as a sensible ownership experience. (unless you have far too much money burning a hole in your pocket!) I am doing a bit of racing thse days and had a good look at the Evora as we circulated in the Britcar 24hr race -- it does look very well planted and I did start to lust after one for track use. Then 2 things happened, it did not finish anywhere as high as it should of done despite having top drivers (technical gremlins)-- then talking to the Lotus guys they wanted something well over £130k for a similar car. No sense in that when there are 996/7 Cup cars available completely refreshed for about half that money.
 
Hi Paul, worry not, still here! [:D] There is only one thing about the Evora I would have on my Cayman, and that is it's slightly more compliant suspension. The Cayman is fabulous on smooth flowing roads, but is a bit too stiffly sprung for the bumpy back roads of Fife. Porsche (and others) would do well to remember that cars spend 99% of their lives on roads, not circuits!
 
John more compliant................. even Porsche cut a few corners when they make cars and it is easier/cheaper for them to stiffly spring the car and get by with some 'one size fits all' non-adjustable shocks! It sounds as if a set of decent aftermarket 2 way adjustables would enhance your Cayman experience no end ie and as the shocks would be more sophisticated the spring rates could be softened a little as well. You'd have no end of fun optimising the set up on those gorgeous roads around you!
 
It sounds even meaner, too. The supercharger whine is audible, but it can’t ruin the spectacular soundtrack coming from behind your head. Fitted as standard to the ‘S’ is an active exhaust which opens a set of valves in the exhaust above 4,700rpm to increase the volume, although our car was fitted with the optional sports exhaust which turns the volume up to maximum at all times Read more: http://www.autoexpress.co.uk/carreviews/firstdrives/259012/lotus_evora_s.html#ixzz15M1tWIOP Why don't Porsche take a leaf out of Lotus's book and let their sports cars sound like sports cars in this fashion too and rework their future PSE options to compete[&o]
 

Posts made and opinions expressed are those of the individual forum members

Use of the Forum is subject to the Terms and Conditions

Disclaimer

The opinions expressed on this site are not necessarily those of the Club, who shall have no liability in respect of them or the accuracy of the content. The Club assumes no responsibility for any effects arising from errors or omissions.

Porsche Club Great Britain gives no warranties, guarantees or assurances and makes no representations or recommendations regarding any goods or services advertised on this site. It is the responsibility of visitors to satisfy themselves that goods and/or services supplied by any advertiser are bona fide and in no instance can the Porsche Club Great Britain be held responsible.

When responding to advertisements please ensure that you satisfy yourself of any applicable call charges on numbers not prefixed by usual "landline" STD Codes. Information can be obtained from the operator or the white pages. Before giving out ANY information regarding cars, or any other items for sale, please satisfy yourself that any potential purchaser is bona fide.

Directors of the Board of Porsche Club GB, Club Office Staff, Register Secretaries and Regional Organisers are often requested by Club members to provide information on matters connected with their cars and other matters referred to in the Club Rules. Such information, advice and assistance provided by such persons is given in good faith and is based on the personal experience and knowledge of the individual concerned.

Neither Porsche Club GB, nor any of the aforementioned, shall be under any liability in respect of any such information, advice or assistance given to members. Members are advised to consult qualified specialists for information, advice and assistance on matters connected with their cars at all times.

Back
Top