Menu toggle

My mpg gone done?

jeegnesh

New member
My driving style has not changed, I used to get 26-27mpg I now see that I am on 22-23mpg

Could this be air mass sensor? Mine was last changed about 4 years ago?
 

Assuming you're not getting an engine warning light, it could be a partially-malfuntioning MAF or oxygen sensor - or any other sensor interfacing with the DME for that matter! If performance is down a bit too, it could be a blocked injector or a leak in the inlet or exhaust system.

If you're really concerned it would be advisable to get someone to run a full diagnostic check (PIWIS or Durametric).

Jeff
 
Just come out of the garage. New AOS did have an air leak, new bank sensors and coil packs very recently (due to engine light, misfiring), been serviced. Actually driving nicely just the mpg has gone down which was true prior to the service too. Has been on some computer will have to check what that was actually.
 

ORIGINAL: jeegnesh

New AOS did have an air leak ......

Are you sure that there isn't still an AOS air leak - in a hose perhaps?

It might be upsetting the A/F ratio governed by the MAF/DME.

Jeff

 

ORIGINAL: Motorhead


ORIGINAL: jeegnesh

New AOS did have an air leak ......

Are you sure that there isn't still an AOS air leak - in a hose perhaps?

It might be upsetting the A/F ratio governed by the MAF/DME.

Jeff

Can't be sure would have thought if anything was out of range it would have come when they put it on the computer.

Damn it's driving real nice though.
 

Who knows Jeegnesh...?

There are so many sensors in the fuelling control loop: MAF, air and coolant temp, oxygen, etc., any one (or more) of which could be borderline and not showing up during the check.

If it's driving well, perhaps the engine's over-fuelling slightly, leading to the drop in fuel consumption you're experiencing. Are your exhaust tailpipes blackened more than usual? That would be a sign.

Jeff
 
Doesn't seem to blackened more then usual, can't say I'm an expert on that. As everything seems to be fine may have to leave well alone and enjoy.
 
how can you check if its overfuelling-my tips have been blackened for a few months now!!
 
ORIGINAL: dyllan
how can you check if its overfuelling-my tips have been blackened for a few months now!!
That exactly what I found, they have always been kind of black so really would not be able to tell any difference.
 

ORIGINAL: jeegnesh

ORIGINAL: dyllan
how can you check if its overfuelling-my tips have been blackened for a few months now!!
That exactly what I found, they have always been kind of black so really would not be able to tell any difference.


If you cruise on a light throttle should be able to get tips to go grey. [;)]
 

ORIGINAL: smbaker


ORIGINAL: jeegnesh

ORIGINAL: dyllan
how can you check if its overfuelling-my tips have been blackened for a few months now!!
That exactly what I found, they have always been kind of black so really would not be able to tell any difference.


If you cruise on a light throttle should be able to get tips to go grey. [;)]

Just a suggestion but now that the weather's good, get the hood down, give it some welly in second gear and see if you're trailing an excessive amount of black smoke. If you remove the wind deflector, you might possibly get to smell something too due to air recirculation?

Of course, it could just be your driving style Jeegnesh! Maybe you should try driving economically to see what you can achieve and then you can decide how you want to drive.

Jeff
 

ORIGINAL: Motorhead


ORIGINAL: smbaker


ORIGINAL: jeegnesh

ORIGINAL: dyllan
how can you check if its overfuelling-my tips have been blackened for a few months now!!
That exactly what I found, they have always been kind of black so really would not be able to tell any difference.


If you cruise on a light throttle should be able to get tips to go grey. [;)]

Just a suggestion but now that the weather's good, get the hood down, give it some welly in second gear and see if you're trailing an excessive amount of black smoke. If you remove the wind deflector, you might possibly get to smell something too due to air recirculation?

Of course, it could just be your driving style Jeegnesh! Maybe you should try driving economically to see what you can achieve and then you can decide how you want to drive.

Jeff
[:)] he he, I got my family 4x4 for that, think I'll forget about it because to be honest it's never driven so well since my ownership as it is right now. I also find the more you drive it including going through the rev range the less problems the car gives, the more idle the car is left seems to invite trouble, so my new goal is to use it as much as I can :)
 

A very sensible plan Jeegnesh!

But if the problem does get worse and you're getting concerned about it, I think that you're going to have to check out it out more thoroughly. As I said in an earlier post, despite the fact that you've had it checked out (on a PIWIS or Durametric system?), there might be a slight problem with one or more sensor,injector,etc., or there might be an inlet or exhaust sytem leak.

Unfortunately, I don't have any first-hand experience using either system so can't comment on their ability to pinpoint a fault on a specific item but as a starting point, I'd check that the MAF sensor and the Lambda (O2) sensors aren't contaminated and appear to be functioning correctly; access to these items is relatively straightforward too. Opinions seem to be divided as to whether or not the MAF sensor can be cleaned satisfactorily but whatever you do, it's possible that you're going to be into component swapping, which is likely to prove expensive. Maybe best just to take the hit in fuel bills..!

Enjoy your summer drives and keep us posted if you do manage to effect a cure.

Jeff
 
Thanks Jeff, considering I had a very expensive last year changing a lot of components, I think as long as I stay above 20mpg I will leave alone, currently running at 23mpg (driven overenthusiastic) and wait till a point I feel like ofloading more cash (unlikely :) )

I do think MAF sensor is my first port of call I think mine is 5+ years old looking at receipts so I strongly believe that may well be the cause.

Besides I have this overwhelming urge to get the swirl marks removed, I have tried myself but don't think I am patient enough for the job, but also hurts spending so much just to remove them, it looks amazing from a distance :)
 

ORIGINAL: jeegnesh

Besides I have this overwhelming urge to get the swirl marks removed, I have tried myself but don't think I am patient enough for the job, but also hurts spending so much just to remove them, it looks amazing from a distance :)

One of the downsides of black(?) cars Jeegnesh. My Cayman's arctic silver, so swirl marks aren't really a problem unless the body's viewed under arc lamps.!

I read somewhere that Autoglym's Super Resin Polish is good for filling the swirl marks, followed up by the application of a good carnauba wax to seal the surface. I know that it's only a temporary fix but it'd much cheaper than handing the car over to the "Detailing Posse" and you'd have the satifaction of having done it all yourself..!!

Jeff
 
You can check the maf quite easilly.
Engage gear and from tickover give it the beans - if the maf is playing up you will find the acceleration hesitates at some point between tickover speed and max revs - you will feel this "hesitation" it is noticable because the power seems to diminish then comes alive a little higher up the revs.
A very cheap fix, to be honest if you suspect it just fit a new one - if that doesnt solve your problem you will know you have a good working maf as a spare.
The maf is a regular issue so by getting a new one and having a spare will save you money down the road as you will save when the price rises because you already have the spare (does that make sense?)
 
Thanks Jeff, think I may try that out over the summer, sounds alot more reasonable to me.

Glyn tried your test through the rev range and there is no hesitation, tried it on some big roads too and pulled all the way through, so I guess the MAF sensor is working fine.
 
Hi Jeegnesh,

Let me know if your problem is cured by changing the MAF. I do not keep tabs on my MPG but I do have a flat spot between 3k-4k rpm . just the point where the cams/ manifold change over and always though it was "normal " condition. But I think this could be a MAF by the posts above.

 

ORIGINAL: GOOFY

Hi Jeegnesh,

Let me know if your problem is cured by changing the MAF. I do not keep tabs on my MPG but I do have a flat spot between 3k-4k rpm . just the point where the cams/ manifold change over and always though it was "normal " condition. But I think this could be a MAF by the posts above.
Long time, still loving the silver emblem :) I don't plan to change the MAF just yet I am not flat spotting anywhere, need to service my X5 currently so will divert funds there for the time being plus lost a 3mpg but driving beautifully can live with that.
 
My emissions warning light came on, and has gone back off since, but its my bank 2 sensor 1, o2 sensor fault and im only getting around 16 / 17 mpg!
 

Posts made and opinions expressed are those of the individual forum members

Use of the Forum is subject to the Terms and Conditions

Disclaimer

The opinions expressed on this site are not necessarily those of the Club, who shall have no liability in respect of them or the accuracy of the content. The Club assumes no responsibility for any effects arising from errors or omissions.

Porsche Club Great Britain gives no warranties, guarantees or assurances and makes no representations or recommendations regarding any goods or services advertised on this site. It is the responsibility of visitors to satisfy themselves that goods and/or services supplied by any advertiser are bona fide and in no instance can the Porsche Club Great Britain be held responsible.

When responding to advertisements please ensure that you satisfy yourself of any applicable call charges on numbers not prefixed by usual "landline" STD Codes. Information can be obtained from the operator or the white pages. Before giving out ANY information regarding cars, or any other items for sale, please satisfy yourself that any potential purchaser is bona fide.

Directors of the Board of Porsche Club GB, Club Office Staff, Register Secretaries and Regional Organisers are often requested by Club members to provide information on matters connected with their cars and other matters referred to in the Club Rules. Such information, advice and assistance provided by such persons is given in good faith and is based on the personal experience and knowledge of the individual concerned.

Neither Porsche Club GB, nor any of the aforementioned, shall be under any liability in respect of any such information, advice or assistance given to members. Members are advised to consult qualified specialists for information, advice and assistance on matters connected with their cars at all times.

Back
Top