Menu toggle

Repairs - which is most urgent?

dickreuter

New member
My Porsche Center in West London called me and told me I needed to do the following repairs in addition to a major service. I'm a bit surprised as the car just passed the MOT a couple of weeks ago and I'm quite sure they would have spotted at least some of those items. Any opinions of what is most urgent?

coil pack split and front diff.seals leaking oil £890 inc vat
front discs rusty and past wear limit pads 90% worn £910 inc vat
High tone Horn not working £160 inc vat

Can I fix some of it myself or bring it to an alternative garage where it is cheaper?

thanks
Nicolas
 
I'd say the discs 'rusty' is a bit of a typical OPC yarn... and personally would get them done by an indy rather than an OPC.

The High Tone Horn has gone on mine too, but I'm sure it's a 20 minute job for a novice. Just not sure where it is.

Don't know know about the coil pack and seal, but they are probably "things that could do with doing" rather than urgent.
 
The split coil pack could apparently make it difficult to start the car, but I've never had the slightest problem so far. The brake pads can't be that bad otherwise it wouldn't have passed the MOT, right?
 
If the wear indicator light isn't on you will have at lease 5mm of material on the pads. Coil packs are a common problem, and they tend to work fine unit the insulation breaks down to the point of creating a misfire.

Find yourself a decent independent, and you will probably save 40-50% on those prices. Where are you located? There are plenty of indies in the West London Area.
 
Jaz at Wembley
GT One at Chertsey
Tognola Engineering at Datchet

These are ones I have heard good things about, but I'm sure someone else may know somewhere closer.
 
Apart from the situation with the brakes, which as pointed out is a dealership special.... none of the other items would be involved within the MOT.

The horn sounded and thats all thats required.

Its a common mis-conception that just that the car past an MOT it is actually in good condition.

garyw
 
Nicolas,

The OPC's comments on the brakes might assume you won't have the car looked at again until the next service. For ease of mind, it's worth having an independent look at all the things suggested by them.

You could try Leigh who's based on the Seagrave Road, West Brompton. No affiliation and he's been looking after Porsches for 30-odd years, so I'd say he know his onions (or porks) [;)]. He uses Porsche OEM parts. The saving is in the labour rate and piece of mind that the person woking on your car will do only the necessary jobs and do them properly. PM if you want his details.

My brake pads went a further 3,000 miles from the moment the OPC said to keep an eye on them. At the very least, as Richard says, the light should come on in the car / turn up on the on board computer.

HTH

SNDa
 
Don't do it!! Step away from the OPC!!
I was told that my front discs needed replacing two years/3000 miles/2 MOTs ago! I was washing the car and NOT driving it straight afterwards to get heat into them to dry them off - what a tit! I now do get them hot - really hot - before putting it back to bed and no problems since!!
Coil packs - apparently some of mine are split - but the engine is running like a watch. I'm not touching them until they become symptomatic.
Horn - I used to squirt loads of water up underneath my front P.U. (spoiler) when washing the car. The high tone horn faces the ground so all the crap and water goes up into it. It's one of Porsche's classic designs! I had mine replaced under warranty ages ago and asked them to position the new one so that it was facing the other way - guess what? No problems since. Ask Richard for one of his fab links on how to get your front P.U. off and DIY.
Your car is road worthy - enough said!
If your front pads are on their way out get some new ones from somewhere like Euro Parts and DIY - it's easy and there's loads of links on this forum about how to do it. Then (when they're done) take the car out and get some serious speedy braking done - the discs will polish up, may be not back to new - but better than they are now. OPC told me that I could not expect to stop in time if I didn't get them done! I told them that "I did not have sexual relations with that woman", "I will not raise taxes" and that "there will be no whitewash in the White House!"
All the best! Adrian.
 
[:)]
Many thanks for all the help. Just drove to southern France and back and had no problems at all, so I was a bit confused about what the dealer told me.

By the way, I got flashed about 5 times on my way in France. Any idea whether they will send the bill to England?
 
Which coil pack? There are 6. They are £35 each. 20 min job don't get OPC to do.

They all split as they are open to the elements but when they go might cause you a few probs until you can get to place to change them....engine light will come on as it will start to misfire.

Main advice.....

DONT EVER GO TO AN OPC....THE GOOD INDEPENDENTS WILL WIPE THE FLOOR WITH THEM EVERY TIME IMHO
 
You're absolutely right of course. It was quite stupid to bring it there, but luckily I was on time to halt all the repairs. Will get it done at one of those you suggested when needed.

I think only one coil pack is split, so hardly a problem. The only thing I'm a bit worried about is the oil leak in the diff. seal. But I've never noticed any oil on the floor so that's probably just another hoax.

 
ORIGINAL: jason

Which coil pack? There are 6. They are £35 each. 20 min job don't get OPC to do.

They all split as they are open to the elements but when they go might cause you a few probs until you can get to place to change them....engine light will come on as it will start to misfire.

Main advice.....

DONT EVER GO TO AN OPC....THE GOOD INDEPENDENTS WILL WIPE THE FLOOR WITH THEM EVERY TIME IMHO
Forest Fine have coil packs for £21.50 each. http://www.forestfine.com/ Bit more than a 20 min job - it's fiddly (esp. nos 1 and 4) - but as long as you can get the car up on a ramp (and you have the right ools of course) you can do it yourself without too much bother.
 
I did mean for an independant rather than the individual....and yes some are 'a little' quicker to do than others...

Get the diff leak checked though.
 
there is no reciprocal arrangement with france so any camera flashes you can wave at with impunity....just like the gallic guys do to ours[:D]
the only time you need worry is when the jolly blue b******s arrive on your shoulder with a strong desire for your euros and a big gun[:mad:]
 
Get yourself a snooper indigo anyway for the cameras in France--it wont be long before all european speeding offences come back to haunt you. Just came back from Champagne--could not do without the snooper-a great bit of kit. ps. I would not go to the OPC's either. Someone has to pay for the pretty girls at reception!!!!!
 
ORIGINAL: nickmason
Get yourself a snooper indigo anyway for the cameras in France--it wont be long before all european speeding offences come back to haunt you.

Yes, that way they can fine you and remove it from your car to add to the pain.. they are illegal in France...
We were in Champagne last weekend and never managed to set off any cameras, we were though very lucky with the speed trap coming into the toll booths towards Calais...[&:]

garyw
 
ORIGINAL: dickreuter


I think only one coil pack is split, so hardly a problem.

I think it worth getting the coil done because misfires can damage the catalytic converters, and they're expensive. [also, a Porsche Centre will tend to mention a leak if there's any sign of dampness].
 
ORIGINAL: garyw

ORIGINAL: nickmason
Get yourself a snooper indigo anyway for the cameras in France--it wont be long before all european speeding offences come back to haunt you.

Yes, that way they can fine you and remove it from your car to add to the pain.. they are illegal in France...
We were in Champagne last weekend and never managed to set off any cameras, we were though very lucky with the speed trap coming into the toll booths towards Calais...[&:]

garyw

Hi Gary

If the snooper indigo is a GPS based device it is legal in France (although not in Switzerland). It's active detectors that are illegal. You can buy GPS based radar warning devices in French motorway services, and also maps with fixed camera locations marked on them

Cheers

Pete
 

Posts made and opinions expressed are those of the individual forum members

Use of the Forum is subject to the Terms and Conditions

Disclaimer

The opinions expressed on this site are not necessarily those of the Club, who shall have no liability in respect of them or the accuracy of the content. The Club assumes no responsibility for any effects arising from errors or omissions.

Porsche Club Great Britain gives no warranties, guarantees or assurances and makes no representations or recommendations regarding any goods or services advertised on this site. It is the responsibility of visitors to satisfy themselves that goods and/or services supplied by any advertiser are bona fide and in no instance can the Porsche Club Great Britain be held responsible.

When responding to advertisements please ensure that you satisfy yourself of any applicable call charges on numbers not prefixed by usual "landline" STD Codes. Information can be obtained from the operator or the white pages. Before giving out ANY information regarding cars, or any other items for sale, please satisfy yourself that any potential purchaser is bona fide.

Directors of the Board of Porsche Club GB, Club Office Staff, Register Secretaries and Regional Organisers are often requested by Club members to provide information on matters connected with their cars and other matters referred to in the Club Rules. Such information, advice and assistance provided by such persons is given in good faith and is based on the personal experience and knowledge of the individual concerned.

Neither Porsche Club GB, nor any of the aforementioned, shall be under any liability in respect of any such information, advice or assistance given to members. Members are advised to consult qualified specialists for information, advice and assistance on matters connected with their cars at all times.

Back
Top