Menu toggle

RS Is It Better Than The Porsche!

daro911

PCGB Member
Member
Audi's performance arm is on a roll.

Quattro Gmbh, the official name for Audi's go-faster division, has created not only the sensational RS4 but fathered the sublime R8 supercar and unleashed the insanely fast RS6.

So when news comes of another all-new RS it's no surprise the performance world sits up and pays attention.

After all, the RS engineers don't believe in half measures; remember it was them who thought dropping a turbocharged version of a Lamborghini V10 into a family car was a good idea. Perhaps then it's no surprise the TT's existing 2.0-litre turbo and 3.2 V6 engines didn't measure up to their high expectations. A more suitable alternative was needed.

But the engineers couldn't find one. Both the RS4's 4.2 V8 and S4's new supercharged 3.0 V6 were too bulky and heavy for the light TT body, forcing the RS team to start again from scratch.

The result is the all-new 2.5-litre five-cylinder turbo that pays homage to the legendary Audi ur-Quattro of the Eighties.

Pumping out a healthy 335bhp, the new engine gifts the TT with searing performance. The 0-62mph sprint takes the RS just 4.6 seconds, making the small Audi coupe as quick as the R8 supercar. Pay Audi to remove the limiter and the RS tops out at an unbelievable 174mph.

To help underline the TT's new-found muscle the RS gains an aggressive new look. In come R8-style wider air intakes up front, as well as an aggressive new body kit and a big ugly rear spoiler ensure. Subtle it isn't.

Prices for the new car start at £42,980 for the TT RS coupe, and the roadster will set you back £44,880. Both versions are pitched head-to-head with the talented Porsche Cayman and Boxster S.

With the new engine both TT RS versions are significantly faster than the Porsches, but crucially it's not all about straight-line speed. Is it better than the Porsches? Read on to find out.

Audi finished a decent seventh place in the most recent 2008 JD Power survey behind Mercedes and Jaguar.
The TT specifically didn't feature in the survey, but built on a policy of parts-sharing there's nothing to say the sporty Audi coupe shouldn't be no more or less reliable than an A3.

Nowadays, that's a good thing because the first generation of TT suffered from the odd faulty electrical faults and failing instrument panels.

Until the RS arrived the TT, like many other Audis, led the class for fit and finish and the quality of its cabin, but at almost £10,000 more than the next most expensive TT, is the RS outshone by new similarly priced competition?

Not at all. It's a credit to Audi's choice of high quality materials and beautiful build that the TT is still pick of the bunch even at this rather hefty price. To help justify the extra cash the RS gains plenty of brushed aluminium inlays, RS logos and heated leather seats plus a sportier, flat-bottomed steering wheel.

On paper the new RS Audi leads the coupe class with its explosive performance, while in the flesh it finally packs the visual aggression but can it finally outdrive the class-leading Porsche Cayman?

Sadly, the short and brutal answer is no, but the RS comes closer than any TT before. After the sensational RS4 and sublime R8, you can't blame us for expecting more.

Let's start with the positive.

The new 335bhp 2.5-litre 5-cylinder is a gem. From standstill to 62mph the Audi coupe outguns all its rivals taking just 4.6 seconds. Aiding its blistering getaway from the line is the superb traction provided by the Haldex 4x4 system that efficiently shuffles torque to the axle with most grip, and it is torque that dominates in the RS.

With the maximum 332lb-ft delivered from just 1,600rpm the new engine has a broad spread of power and decent go anywhere in the rev range.

Where a Cayman would require third for blistering exit from a medium speed corner the Audi will suffice with fourth.

Emphasising the TT's strong overtaking performance is a close-ratio gearbox that is both snappy and fast to use. Perversely, despite Audi pioneering the technology, the double clutch DSG, is not offered on the RS.

That said, close-ratio box or not, away from traffic-light grands prix and cross country the RS doesn't feel substantially quicker than the equivalent Cayman S.

A quick look at the tech sheet and it's easy to see why. The RS is burdened with a 100kg (the weight of a portly adult) weight handicap that blunts the Audi's power-to-weight ratio. Even with 'just' 315bhp the Porsche has the fractionally superior power-to-weight ratio that helps claw back some ground over the blistering Audi, although this advantage would shrink in damp or slippery conditions where the Porsche's rear-wheel drive would be no match for the TT's all-wheel-drive traction advantage.

Strangely, for perhaps for what's supposed to be the most extreme and hardcore TT, the RS uses the speed-sensitive power steering that feels supermini-light at parking speeds.

At speed we'd also prefer a more predictable and linear weighting and more feeling. The RS also is less playful, responding less to mid-corner throttle inputs, instead preferring to shrug off a series of corners with its huge reserves of grip. It's fast and neat, thanks to the torque-juggling abilities of the Haldex all-wheel-drive system.

It is tidy and organised but it's less fun than the Cayman S, which isn't so clinical in the way it goes about its work. The Porsche also feels the better balanced of the two and far more adjustable even if its rear-wheel-drive isn't always the fastest way out of the bend.

The Porsche has also got finer, more communicative steering, although the 3.4-litre will need working far harder with its peakier torque delivery. With the howling flat-six soundtrack that's no chore.
 
The 0-62mph sprint takes the RS just 4.6 seconds, making the small Audi coupe as quick as the R8 supercar.
So, here's a maker who is not afraid of allowing their "lesser" models perform as well as the top ones...

But yet again, Porsche handling outshines the opposition.
 
I think Porsche should pay serious Attention to Audi..

I have a foot in both camps, love them both .. Boxster S and RS6 ... two completely different cars...

Boxster S had its 2 year service today .. just short of 600 GBP with nothing needing doing apart from oil and brake fluid change .. We skipped the ridiculous 3rd year warranty

I think the RS6 may be cheaper to run ....[:eek:]
 
ORIGINAL: gdavison

I think Porsche should pay serious Attention to Audi..

Boxster S had its 2 year service today .. just short of 600 GBP with nothing needing doing apart from oil and brake fluid change .. We skipped the ridiculous 3rd year warranty

Wait until the next service very little extra to do but a whopping £930+ unless you supply your own sensibly priced Mobil 1 in which case its a very reasonable £810+ [:eek:] My car never went into the workshop to after 1.00pm yet was ready for me that night at 6.00 As I had dropped car the off at 7.30am deliberately so it would be ready that night which the receptionist was fully aware of. Hence when I called at 3.00pm to confirm all was done and dusted they confessed it had only been in workshop an hour or two! Needless to say I protested strongly and said I will be in at close of business to collect [:)]

Nothing like a bit of pressure to focus an OPC workshop
 
"...look at its substantial rear wing..." - there's someone who's never seen a GT 911!

But this car has a VW engine - so if Porsche own VW (ok, maybe not so likely now) I can't see them allowing Audi to continue to buy it so they can put it in a competitior!
 

Posts made and opinions expressed are those of the individual forum members

Use of the Forum is subject to the Terms and Conditions

Disclaimer

The opinions expressed on this site are not necessarily those of the Club, who shall have no liability in respect of them or the accuracy of the content. The Club assumes no responsibility for any effects arising from errors or omissions.

Porsche Club Great Britain gives no warranties, guarantees or assurances and makes no representations or recommendations regarding any goods or services advertised on this site. It is the responsibility of visitors to satisfy themselves that goods and/or services supplied by any advertiser are bona fide and in no instance can the Porsche Club Great Britain be held responsible.

When responding to advertisements please ensure that you satisfy yourself of any applicable call charges on numbers not prefixed by usual "landline" STD Codes. Information can be obtained from the operator or the white pages. Before giving out ANY information regarding cars, or any other items for sale, please satisfy yourself that any potential purchaser is bona fide.

Directors of the Board of Porsche Club GB, Club Office Staff, Register Secretaries and Regional Organisers are often requested by Club members to provide information on matters connected with their cars and other matters referred to in the Club Rules. Such information, advice and assistance provided by such persons is given in good faith and is based on the personal experience and knowledge of the individual concerned.

Neither Porsche Club GB, nor any of the aforementioned, shall be under any liability in respect of any such information, advice or assistance given to members. Members are advised to consult qualified specialists for information, advice and assistance on matters connected with their cars at all times.

Back
Top