The only way to diagnose it is to get the fault codes read, then post on here and Richard will no doubt have the full set of parameters relating to each fault code. You can then make an informed decision. All I can say is that I tried my independent's known good maf and for several days all was ok, then after having lifted off after a second gear squirt down a slip road to blend in with traffic, I stood on the gas and the car cut completey for about two seconds. When it cut in again I had PASM/ABS and CEL warnings
Now that I have replaced the throttle body, ok lets give it its proper name throttle adjuster, which is a servo or stepper motor built into the throttle body which actually moves the butterfly via a series of three reduction gears, I no longer have any issues, no barely perceptible hesitation, no CEL no 1,800 rpm idle, and no ABS or PASM warning. As ever the rub is the cost of the two components. I just got fed up with messing around with MAF sensors and did the Sherlock Holmes thing where when ever you have eliminated the impossible what ever remains is the truth no matter how improbable, so I had £675 worth of faith in my MAF.
So, if you get the P1101 Input charge variable-above limit fault code, and look down the diagnostic tree, there are two components associated with this code, MAF and throttle/throttle adjuster, which I take to mean the butterly and its spindles, considered separately to the throttle adjuster.
Don't disconnect the battery as the fault codes could clear. When I changed my throttle I disconnected the battery and took it to my indie to get the fault codes read and cleared, but there were none in the system.
I got all sorts of fault codes including some spurious tiptronic codes (6speed manual don't forget) but I am led to believe that tip, throttle angle and presumably speed are interlinked, so the wrong feed back from either MAF or T/B would bring up tip communication errors, but don't take this as gospel this is a bit of conjecture.
- read codes
- eliminate MAF first if code is P1101
- post codes here and ask for help