Menu toggle

Using RAC Breakdown cover? Read this!

cobnut

New member
On Saturday me and the missus were enjoying a drive around the Cotswolds in our 987.1. We'd had a few busy weeks and I'd been in the States all the previous week so we'd been looking forward to some time to ourselves and to enjoy the early autumn scenery. We'd just decided to head back home (we were about 50 miles away) when the front nearside tyre blew out - properly - it sounded like a shotgun blast. Pulled over where I could - it was a narrow lane, but thankfully very little traffic - and a quick inspection revealed that it was down to the wires on far inside. Whoops, looks like I'd missed a fairly serious tracking problem (the rest of the tyre surfaces were legal tread) as the offside one wasn't much better. Lesson learned about properly inspecting tyres, but that's not the point of this story.

With such a blow, it seemed unlikely that the "gloop" would do much good (later confirmed by the tyre replacement guy) so we called the RAC, with whom we have their top-level cover, onward travel, hotels, replacement cars, the lot. On the first call at 14:50 we were asked if we had a spare. This seemed like an odd question, I'd have thought in today's world their systems would know whether a particular make/model carried a spare, but anyway, no, we haven't. "OK, we don't do wheel replacement, but we'll send a truck out, should be there before 18:00". Six 'o'clock? Well, that was longer than I'd hoped, but it was a nice day, I had a good signal to listen to the cricket and we had some water and snacks, so not much more to do.

16:00 we call again just to make sure everything's on track. "Yes, it's all good, he'll be there before 6pm."

17:00 call again, just to check progress. "Yes, he'll be there between 5:17 and 6pm, and the good news is they're usually closer to the early time, so it shouldn't be long now."

18:00 comes and goes, and when the cricket finishes at 18:30 we call to ask where our guy is. "The system is showing 150 minutes from now." WHAT? Two and a half hours from now, that's nine 'o' clock!! What happened to the guy that had a precise arrival time. "Sorry, I can't see what's been said before, all I can see is that it'll be 150 minutes from now. Couldn't you call a mobile tyre service?" By this time I'm ranting. We'd already been there over 3.5 hours, it was getting dark and it was no longer fun and that made me snap slightly... "Well, yes, possibly we could have done if that had been proposed to us at ten to three, but it's now half-past six and the chances of finding a tyre for my car are less than zero. But why the hell should we when we're paying you for recovery?" etc. etc. I demanded to speak to a supervisor to which the guy replied by hanging up. Great.

Seconds later my missus gets a call on her phone (the one we'd originally placed the call on) and it's a breakdown firm in Lechlade, about 20 miles away, saying they'll be there in 45 minutes. Er... great, but why are the RAC telling us it'll be 9pm? "Dunno, he says, I've just got the call". 45 minutes comes and goes, and it's now around 19:30, pretty much properly dark. We ring the breakdown service direct and they say he's on his way, he'll be there in 20 minutes, and he was. So, 10 minutes later (he was very efficient), the car's on the back, we're in the cab and we're on the move. Story over, right? No.

As we're driving away the guy (Jake) says "I've got to tell you this, the RAC marked this as a roadside assistance, don't know why, we don't do roadside tyre replacement, but that's how the job is marked so I can only drive you a maximum of 10 miles to the nearest place of safety." What??? "If you need onwards to home, we need to get permission from the RAC, but that usually takes them an hour or more and I can only leave the car on the back for 20 minutes once we've arrived at Shipston."

By this time my missus is in tears and I'm not far behind. We'd had a lovely day up till the blowout, I was relaxing from too many days travelling, she'd bought a new top to wear to a friend's party that night (the likelihood of getting to increasingly small) and now it'd all gone to shit. "So you're saying that now we've finally been picked up, in a truck that's carrying the car, you're going to have to offload it and we start the same process all over again?" "Yeah, sorry, the RAC do this all the time, they're the worst." We sit there in stunned silence for a minute or two before he says "What cover have you got?" "The lot, the total package, the best they do." "Tell you what, I'll get the office to put the call in now to get approval for onwards to home and I'll just take you there now. With a bit of luck the approval will come through before we arrive and they'll be none the wiser, if it doesn't, we can fudge the times." Thank you, finally someone with some common sense.

So in the end we get home at around 21:45, slot the car into a parking space and see Jake off with a handshake, a huge hug from my missus and a generous tip he tried damned hard to refuse.

I'm planning to write to the RAC, but to be honest I know nothing will happen. I will cancel the sub, and try to get a refund of what's been paid so far, but I'm not hopeful. According to Jake and the nice guy who's just been and replaced both fronts, Green Flag are the best for customer service, not least because you'll deal directly with a local service after the call is placed.

With the RAC? Think again.

Jon
 
Sorry not a good experience ...last year I ran over a bolt in the road and tyre went flat with in seconds ,I tried to blow it up with my tyre inflator to no avail ,called out the RAC who turned up in around 90 min .On inspection the bolt had gone right through the inside tyre wall so it was US .He then gave me two options take me home (15 mins away to be fair) using there multi fit wheel and tyre which they carry or take me to a local garage to get a replacement done ,opted for the tyre service but on arrival they could not get the same tyre a Michelin till the next day and are not insured to have customers cars left overnight ,so the RAC guy offered to come back the next day and collect his spare so I could drive the car home 5 mins away, then the garage offered to fit a spare wheel and tyre they had till the new one arrived in the morning so a result .
 
I had a similar experience with the AA with my motorcycle ... ended up calling a private bike collection company after waiting 5 hours in central London ... The AA sent a van that couldn’t recover a motorcycle. I left the bike and keys with a friendly Shell garage conveniently nearby and took a taxi home!
 
Not surprised - I had the same problem with Green Flag 18 months ago when my wife's Audi TTS hit a plank of wood at 70 mph that had fallen off a lorry and had a double wheel puncture - they fouled it up big time. Best resort is obtaining email address of the CEO with your problem. Get some compensation and then chnge rescue service! Saying that, I changed to the RAC !!!! Watch this space. CEO of the RAC is David Hobday
 
Regrettably I wouldn't use this as an indication of the service (or lack thereof) by the RAC but the industry as a whole.

In close to 40 years I've been with the AA, RAC and AA again as well as having cover within my car insurance and can relate to the tale above almost to the word in pretty much every case. Even down to the "We can only take you to xxxxxx, oh well perhaps we can take you all the way home after all".

Not that I, or members of my family, are habitually breaking down but when ever it happens, morning, noon night evening etc. etc. the "service" are always "experiencing a busy period". The times for the arrival of assistance are always significant and almost never achieved despite the initial ludicrous wait.

Which ever service you choose seems to almost always use 3rd party contractors now. These same contractors are on call to the Police for RTA's when, I assume, they get a premium so guess what takes precedence. And they certainly aren't sitting in their cabs with their engines running ready to respond to a call at the drop of a hat. If their dinner is about to go on the table they may or may not respond to the dispatchers call to your assistance. If they do, but say it will be 3 hours, the dispatcher takes that as a tick in the box and moves on. They certainly don't try to find another contractor who might be able to get to you in half an hour.

The whole service needs a damn good shake up.
 
Thanks for the support and the stories folks, she's all better now with new shoes (and the tracking sorted out!).

I've just looked at Green Flag and they have the same 10-mile limit for tyres (flats or damaged), which leaves me thinking we'd potentially be in the same situation if there's another tyre problem. I've only had a couple of "proper" breakdowns in 35 years of driving, but I've had probably 10 flat tyres (either potholes or screws, etc.). Most of the cars I've have had a spare, so it's usually been a minor inconvenience (apart from one spectacular hole in Hampshire that blew both nearside tyres and cracked both alloys), but I've no desire to go through anything like what happened on Saturday again. Been chatting to Green Flag and they assure me they'd do it better, taking us home without fuss and arranging pick up the next day to take the car to be repaired, but, of course, they would say that, as I'm sure the RAC or AA would, if you asked them now.

Is there not a service specifically for "unusual" cars/tyres that is either better prepared to simply pick the car up and take it somewhere and/or has access to the rarer tyre sizes? Seems like a hole in the market, even Porsche Assistance seems picky about tyres...

J
 
Well, on the back of the terrible service from RAC, I'm pleased to say that the Co-op Insurance services (who provided the RAC cover as part of the insurance package) couldn't have been better. I've just contacted them via live chat to try and cancel/refund the RAC cover and it was done in less than a minute. Couldn't have been easier. Maybe the Co-op should look at running their own breakdown service...

Jon
 
I have used Green Flag for four events (none for tyres / none for Porsche ) in the past seven years. Their agents have always been quite prompt and helpful although their priority was always to recover than to repair ... hence none of them came properly equipped to repair, most not even carrying water.

They recently did me a split service whereby they dropped me & the car home and when I could not repair it myself the next day they came and recovered me to a garage ... great service.

Watch out for the small print whereby they will not come out for the same issue within 28 days.
 
What a mess of an experience and glad your family are all safe eventually.

On a more of a success story we get AA with our bank service, last year had a very similar blow out on M3 in the Cayenne around 10am on Sunday morning. Luckily it was around 100m from enterance to the Services at Fleet, puled into car park and say similar damage to inside edge of rear tyre. Called AA and wandered into services to get a coffee. Guy arrived before the coffee ! He took one look at agreed it was a non started on any "repair". His temp "fit any car tyre" cannot be used for 4*4's, he spends next 30 mins on phone ane finds an open tyre fitting service about 30 mins away with a matching Yokohama N rated tyre, loads me and my flat into his van, drives over to fitters, leaving Mrs D looking after the Cayenne on a jack in the car park. New tyre fitted and balanced and we headed back to fit to car .. All nicely sorted and we drive home. Two weeks later I got a 75 Quid fine for not buying parking at the M3 services and exceeding 2 hours. I wrote to them including a photo of tyre and car on jack explaining we had not really "parked" out of choice and they waived the charge

It probably so depends on the area of the brake down, time of day, other events in the areas etc

interesting when I got OPC to check tracking I had a "no fault found - all well in spec" .. so why I had a single rear tyre go down to wires on inner side I (and OPC) have no idea
 
I'll throw in a vote for Green Flag (although I did read above it's not perfect either). Switched to them 30 years ago after poor experience elsewhere and I've probably had half a dozen incidents and always been very impressed by how organized and fast they are. Even ignored the "28 day repeat" rule when my new transit kept blowing turbo pipes before Ford decided it was a recall problem.

We use the family policy that allows any number of cars for 2 drivers - and you don't need to tell them what cars you have (although they won't come out if a random car is over 15 (I think) years old - so my 993 is registered as the main car on the policy)
 

Posts made and opinions expressed are those of the individual forum members

Use of the Forum is subject to the Terms and Conditions

Disclaimer

The opinions expressed on this site are not necessarily those of the Club, who shall have no liability in respect of them or the accuracy of the content. The Club assumes no responsibility for any effects arising from errors or omissions.

Porsche Club Great Britain gives no warranties, guarantees or assurances and makes no representations or recommendations regarding any goods or services advertised on this site. It is the responsibility of visitors to satisfy themselves that goods and/or services supplied by any advertiser are bona fide and in no instance can the Porsche Club Great Britain be held responsible.

When responding to advertisements please ensure that you satisfy yourself of any applicable call charges on numbers not prefixed by usual "landline" STD Codes. Information can be obtained from the operator or the white pages. Before giving out ANY information regarding cars, or any other items for sale, please satisfy yourself that any potential purchaser is bona fide.

Directors of the Board of Porsche Club GB, Club Office Staff, Register Secretaries and Regional Organisers are often requested by Club members to provide information on matters connected with their cars and other matters referred to in the Club Rules. Such information, advice and assistance provided by such persons is given in good faith and is based on the personal experience and knowledge of the individual concerned.

Neither Porsche Club GB, nor any of the aforementioned, shall be under any liability in respect of any such information, advice or assistance given to members. Members are advised to consult qualified specialists for information, advice and assistance on matters connected with their cars at all times.

Back
Top