Classic Motor Oil Or Mobile 1

[Macan360]

Hi All

My 996 Carrera 2 is due service next month and talking with local Porsche dealer I have been advised to have the classic service but go with mobile 1 oil.

They have agreed to charge the same price as the classic oil as quoted by Porsche Classic. As I already have mobile 1 top ups and have used it my Cayman S for years I have agreed to go this route. They have concerned that this will meet the requirements of the Classic register and be better for the car.

Is this the correct decision or is there a reason for using the Classic Oil I should know about?

Looking on another post in the Classic register there seems to be a lot of confusion over the oils.

Trevor

 

[CLIFFWILKINS]

Personally I would go with Mobil 1 5/40 for a slightly older car and it maybe has a few miles on it.
But oil is a personal thing .

 

[wibble]

Does the underside of the rear lid not say Mobil1 as approved by Porsche? I'm pretty certain my 944 had a similar sticker.

 

[JHMotorsport]

Cayman295, As mentioned above oil is if course a personal thing and some decide to go their own way for various reasons. If however you do go with the standard spec of Mobil1 then may be helpful to know you can great deal on it at Costco.
I know it’s not much use if you do not have one nearby or are not interested in membership - but if you can get to one then they have a good deal on the suggested 0W40. That is the suggested one that I believe the dealer would use too, also on the Mobil1 website if you use their selector.
I always buy it in bulk so I have plenty to hand and I’m sure you could give it to the dealer to use.
Big debate on having the dealer do oil changes too of course as these are old cars now and dealers may not be the most knowledgable anymore but we won’t get into that on here!

Good luck
J

 

[Macan360]

All

Thanks for the comments. I went for Mobile 1 5W 50 the previous service used 0W 50.

I am however confused over the Porsche approval comments as the statements below come direct from the Porsche Classic oil website.

The experts at Porsche Classic developed these engine oils with the help of engineers at the Porsche Development Centre in Weissach and a German oil supplier, formulating them especially for the requirements of flat engines in 356 and 911 models (including the type 996), all four-cylinder and eight-cylinder engines, such as those in the 924, 928, 944 and 968, as well as the Porsche Boxster type 986. During development, the oil was subject to extensive laboratory and field tests designed to check its running performance and lubrication properties. Porsche Classic Motoroil is available in four different variants: 20W-50, 10W-60, 10W-50 and 5W-50.

13 key facts about Porsche Classic Motoroil:

• Specially formulated for classic air-cooled flat engines
• Developed as a 20W-50 oil for 356, 914 and early air-cooled 911 models with a displacement of up to 2.7 litres
• Developed as a 10W-60 oil for air-cooled 911 models with a displacement of up to 3.0 litres
• Specially formulated for water-cooled four-, six- and eight-cylinder engines
• Developed as a 10W-50 oil for 924, 944, 968 and 928 models
• Developed as a 5W-50 oil for 996 and 986 models
• Tested under laboratory conditions and in the field
• Tailored to work in harmony with former engine and sealing technologies
• Maximum resistance to high temperatures and shear stability
• Optimum wear and corrosion protection
• Engineered by Porsche
• Made in Germany
• Classic, contemporary packaging developed by the Porsche designers in Weissach
• Thanks Trevor