Menu toggle

New M3 are you tempted

Gary

I'd of thought the TT owners wouldn't even have noticed the M/RS brigade dissapearing in your rear view mirror, the TT is so much faster point to point or in a straight line.

Those of us in cooking Porsches its a bit different - again the defense of the enthusiast is the way it feels to drive. What we've got to face up to is to sell enough cars for the 911 to be profitable there is another, larger, group who care about the cars image and a lot of that has to do with the Pub room figures argument. Whether we agree or not.

In that case the appeal of the cooking Porsche is that it is a mini supercar that you can run affordably day to day, sitting on its own between normal lesser cars and the real exotics/supercar manufacturers like Ferrari etc. The aspiration is that even a cooking 91 as a fair slice of the Supercar killing GT3 or Turbo formula

If run of the mill saloons with an upgrade engine are as fast..... kinda blows the image.

We can sit here and be smug and say purity of handling but if the next gen M3 happens to be as fast around the Nurburgring as a C2, that'll start to grate for most of us and harm thsoe resale figures.

Last Gen M3 was 8m15secs identical to a 2nd gen Boxster S which has the same 0 -100 time. the next gen M3 is alleged to be "much quicker" well your only 10 secs from C2 slaying territory and a few more your getting onto C2S space....

One of these new super saloons will be faster round the ring than a stock C2 and might even get close on a C2S.

There is also the other half effect. I was closing on on a 2nd hand 993 until the wife found out that for similar money the Boxster S was as quick. Guess what car I was allowed to buy in the end.

Its taken a further 5 years to get the 911 and even then there were questions around the RS4 because she liked the looks and it was nearly as fast.

In the end this worked in my favour because she insisted we had the x51 to make sure it was faster than a family saloon. She stillw asn't comfortable with the idea that an M5 or M6 would be every bit as fast on a normal road (A road or Motorway) See the pattern!

I agree with the earlier comemnts that large horsepower figures are often misleading but my point is whatever the power figures are the Facelifted 997 is going to have to be much quicker through the gears and round the ring to keep that cache and maitain its premium over the M/RS/AMG mob with a lot of its buyers.
 
Tom, same point stands for the C2 or X51... no limiter!
The M has a limiter 155mph, so at the end of the day we can still be a little smug [;)] as was my point to Scott.[:)]

This thread sadly is one that the classic Porsche owners will be finger wagging at, it reads like we only buy the car for its Brand and performance figures.
I'm pleased to be able to add to the growing comments and points made, part of my ownership is how the car looks, handles and makes me feel, along with the heritage I know and have always looked up to.

At this moment in time buying a performance car is easy shopping, we are currently spoilt for choice...
I've looked around and currently nothing else gives me the passion I feel when owning and driving the Porsche.

garyw
 
ORIGINAL: sawood12

High power and torque figures are all very impressive for grabbing headlines in the motoring press but ultimately it boils down to how much power can the car actually use. The 997S will use all of it's horses, and more than the M3, wereas the M3's horses will be electronically constrained. 0-60 figures are also meaninless - it all boils down to a question of gearing. If you want a car to beat a Porsche to 60 or 100 or 120 then you can gear it to do so, however you are very well compromising the gearing in other areas of the driving envelope. The one thing that Porsche has always done better than any other motoring manufacturer is strike that delicate balance to give you the very best compromise between performance and ride quality and the mirriad of other parameters that need to be balanced. As fine cars as they are the M3 and fast Audi's so far have failed to pull one over the 911, and nothing i've seen or read so far tells me that the status quo is about to change.

997 owners can afford to be smug for a while longer in my opinion!!

Spot on - there are so many undefinable 'Porsche-isms' that make these cars in a different league and I think you just described a few there perfectly.
 
I've recently exchanged my 997C2S for an AM V8 Vantage. Very similar discussions are taking place on their forums about the V8 being underpowered with 'only' 380 bhp and how many other cars are quicker for less money etc. For me it fails to take into account the whole experience of ownership, with straight line performance only being a part of it. In reality how close do any of us get to accessing even 75% of our cars performance whether on a trackday or in day to day use.
Whether it's a Porsche or Aston these cars, to me, are classics with years of tradition behind them, thats been one of my reasons for buying them.

By the way, which car Aston or Porsche, what a debate, they're both so different and so good that either would make me happy. In my dream world have both, a V8 Vantage and a 997 GT3, to cover every occaison[:)]

Tim
 
Tim, you may like this picture then [;)]

iom2007151mediumvx3.jpg
 
ORIGINAL: timhum2002

I've recently exchanged my 997C2S for an AM V8 Vantage. Very similar discussions are taking place on their forums about the V8 being underpowered with 'only' 380 bhp and how many other cars are quicker for less money etc. For me it fails to take into account the whole experience of ownership, with straight line performance only being a part of it. In reality how close do any of us get to accessing even 75% of our cars performance whether on a trackday or in day to day use.
Whether it's a Porsche or Aston these cars, to me, are classics with years of tradition behind them, thats been one of my reasons for buying them.

By the way, which car Aston or Porsche, what a debate, they're both so different and so good that either would make me happy. In my dream world have both, a V8 Vantage and a 997 GT3, to cover every occaison[:)]

Tim

Two options there, it has to be one of

AmV8 soft top for posing and the few sunny days, 911 Turbo for making progress and Winters or
DB9 for daily commute, GT3 for playtime
 
Just received an out-of-the-blue call from BM dealer where I started list for M3 almost 3 yrs ago now to ask if I want to take it forward. At the time I was quite serious but have since somewhat forgotten about it as had not heard from them in that time.

Told dealer would probably not be pursuing order, although a test drive might convince me otherwise. The dealer is going to cross me off the list and although I suspect no one is interested herein can one generally sell places in such lists, i.e. allow someone else to take it without the hassle of buying/selling vehicle and how does one go about it?
 
Im in a similar position, sold my boxster a few months ago and put a deposit on m3, in the mean time i test drove an rs4, fell in love with it and got it, they are now phoning but i keep missing their calls. So id be interested in the answer too.
 
ORIGINAL: garyw

At this moment in time buying a performance car is easy shopping, we are currently spoilt for choice...
I've looked around and currently nothing else gives me the passion I feel when owning and driving the Porsche.

garyw

Gary

I am with you on that. One of my worries when moving from Boxster S to C2S was that I might only be bable to enjoy the 911 properly at very illegal speeds. While this is likely to be true (I never speed [8D] )

I have found on my favourite local roads quite the revese that the 911 gives more feedback and is more fun at legal speeds than the Boxster S

I still want to visit a german autoban or two to see what the beast will do on unrestricted raods

To accept the finger wagging - if I just wanted the purity of drive et al I'd get a 993 and save £50k. For the extra cash I expect it to provide all the traditional porsche virtures plus blow the over inflated german euroboxes into the weeds when required.

The improved performance of the M3/5/6/RS4//5/6 menas that next Prosche I'll probably be dirven to GT3 or TT land
 
ORIGINAL: Bax

Im in a similar position, sold my boxster a few months ago and put a deposit on m3, in the mean time i test drove an rs4, fell in love with it and got it, they are now phoning but i keep missing their calls. So id be interested in the answer too.

lots of info on www.rs246.com
 
I must say the M3 is a very tempting proposition but if you look slightly sideways at the 335d I think 580nm torque at 1700 rpm has got to be monster on motorways and daily driving this has got to be the 3 series to go for - but still will neve have the feel of any Porsche and thats why we buy them and love them.. If what's going to be the parameter for deciding on a satisfying car to drive is motorway 40 - 100 poke then the way of the future is turbo diesel imo. I'm wondering when the Cayenne goes big torque turbo diesel - then we're heading for trouble. Anyone betting there will never be a turbo diesel 911?
 

Posts made and opinions expressed are those of the individual forum members

Use of the Forum is subject to the Terms and Conditions

Disclaimer

The opinions expressed on this site are not necessarily those of the Club, who shall have no liability in respect of them or the accuracy of the content. The Club assumes no responsibility for any effects arising from errors or omissions.

Porsche Club Great Britain gives no warranties, guarantees or assurances and makes no representations or recommendations regarding any goods or services advertised on this site. It is the responsibility of visitors to satisfy themselves that goods and/or services supplied by any advertiser are bona fide and in no instance can the Porsche Club Great Britain be held responsible.

When responding to advertisements please ensure that you satisfy yourself of any applicable call charges on numbers not prefixed by usual "landline" STD Codes. Information can be obtained from the operator or the white pages. Before giving out ANY information regarding cars, or any other items for sale, please satisfy yourself that any potential purchaser is bona fide.

Directors of the Board of Porsche Club GB, Club Office Staff, Register Secretaries and Regional Organisers are often requested by Club members to provide information on matters connected with their cars and other matters referred to in the Club Rules. Such information, advice and assistance provided by such persons is given in good faith and is based on the personal experience and knowledge of the individual concerned.

Neither Porsche Club GB, nor any of the aforementioned, shall be under any liability in respect of any such information, advice or assistance given to members. Members are advised to consult qualified specialists for information, advice and assistance on matters connected with their cars at all times.

Back
Top