You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
What are the differences between 944's and 968's
- Thread starter JaseGT4
- Start date
Neil Haughey
New member
ORIGINAL: TTM
The problem is not really how high the engine can be revved, it's rather its remarkably poor throttle response that makes it feel lazier than it is.
Lightening the flywheel, ditching the barn door AFM, and, to a certain extent, a short runner intake, will help loads.
Don't have that problem in my race car, easier breathing exhaust and ignition tune up usually cures most of that. The last part is rather simple, get shot of the organ pedal and replace with a small metal pedal straight onto the lever which runs in the back of the pedal. It will hit 4k from idle just with a sharp dab on the pedal.
Neil Haughey
New member
ORIGINAL: pauljmcnulty
Power, its as simple as that.
Neil, I understand that, but why try to get more power by doing something to an engine that it's not designed for, when you can get a reliable 400 BHP from a 944 already? How much will you get out of a 968 by doing all the possible modifications, probably not 400 BHP, and you'll be exceeding it's limits? What's the reasoning for trying to get an NA engine to do less than a turbo already offers?
Interesting point about the Alfa engine. My S2 was used in a comparison with an Alfa GTV6, and my Dad owned one. It was a lovely car, but really! Do the GTV6 forums enjoy discussions about 200K mile-plus cars regularly? Would you recommend a GTV6 as a reliable, everyday car? Whilst it was a great car when new, if you were lucky, but it was suffering massive issues at the first MOT, let alone 25 years on. My Dad's had suspension corroded through in under three years, and you didn't want the clutch to go....
Firstly I seriously doubt any of the claims about reliable turbo power, how many of these engines are raced rather than occasionally given 3 or 4 seconds of gas on the street. Secondly I don't really like turbocharging, not because of lag in general coming onto throttle initially but the lag in coming back off it again and then reapplying throttle in a situation such as cornering. I also can't stand how they sound and the 944 turbo in particular is one of the worst sounding cars ever made, like a demented evil hair dryer. Thirdly I am not personally planning on doing anything along these lines with the cars and that wasn't the point, the usual line of just saying if one wants power here is the turbo version is just a bit embarrassing really. No one would say that to the legions of 911 owners who have enjoyed over 50 years of NA tuning. Fourthly I don't care about anything Alfa other than the V6 engine and how they made it sound which is what I was saying, if I liked those cars I would be driving one rather than a 944 but I don't as engines aside they don't really appeal to me.
blade7
Well-known member
ORIGINAL: Neil Haughey
ORIGINAL: pauljmcnulty
Power, its as simple as that.
Neil, I understand that, but why try to get more power by doing something to an engine that it's not designed for, when you can get a reliable 400 BHP from a 944 already? How much will you get out of a 968 by doing all the possible modifications, probably not 400 BHP, and you'll be exceeding it's limits? What's the reasoning for trying to get an NA engine to do less than a turbo already offers?
Interesting point about the Alfa engine. My S2 was used in a comparison with an Alfa GTV6, and my Dad owned one. It was a lovely car, but really! Do the GTV6 forums enjoy discussions about 200K mile-plus cars regularly? Would you recommend a GTV6 as a reliable, everyday car? Whilst it was a great car when new, if you were lucky, but it was suffering massive issues at the first MOT, let alone 25 years on. My Dad's had suspension corroded through in under three years, and you didn't want the clutch to go....
Firstly I seriously doubt any of the claims about reliable turbo power, how many of these engines are raced rather than occasionally given 3 or 4 seconds of gas on the street.
I think for a 400 bhp turbo to last a long time it's probably best if it's a 3.0 running around 1.1 bar boost.
pauljmcnulty
Active member
Going back to road cars, the Porsche 4-cylinder engine offers everything you need in the different guises: from a 924S to a 968, there really isn't a weak spot in the range is there?
Noise often comes up. I was in a supermarket car park recently when a C63 pulled away. Not fast, probably didn't get to 20, but the reaction was every head turned and it wasn't positive.
Personally, I don't want to attract that attention: leave it to the kids with huge exhausts, or mid-life-crisis guys in the AMG cars. I'd rather have a car that doesn't make too much noise. [&:]
Waylander
Active member
Simples a 944 is a 944 you got what you wanted, a 968 is a 968 aand that's it
If you think you should have what the other has or does not have go buy one
All this about fords nd alfas and exhausts you can fit your head in, are your sure you own the right car?
Just intrigued, my long gone youth is telling me 944 but I'm curious.
pauljmcnulty
Active member
Are the seats different, driving position, are the switches in a different place? Same pull as an S2? Are they as hardwearing internally? Most seem to have cloth seats. I've never driven one but they sit well on the road and sound like a good development of the S2?
It's all near identical to the series two 944 inside. Personally, if I was offered an S2 and a standard 968 in identical condition at an identical price I'd take the 944 on looks, others would take the 968. I think overall condition is more important to how they drive now, than having 30BHP more when they were brand new.
Other 944s or the sport/CS 968s are a different comparison, oranges and apples.
Cloth seats are nicer than leather in many ways, especially if you don't have working aircon!
Chrishazle
Active member
The other comment I would make about seats - ignoring the fibreglass things in CS's which, if I ever got into, I'd never be able to get out!! - is the difference between comfort and sports seats. My coupe had comfort seats with Porsche cloth 1/2 leather. They were comfortable, but the lower side and shoulder bolsters gave not enough support when driving enthusiastically. They were, however, easy getting in and out. The cab has full leather sports seats. These are more difficult on entry and exit, but once in are really comfortable - and give good support when driving enthusiastically. As Paul says above, leather can be a bit awkward on entry on really hot or really cold days, but in a cab if it's hot you have the roof down, and if it's really cold you tend to leave her in her garage! Our shopping trolley is also full leather, with aircon. From choice I would go for leather over cloth.
The other difference between 944's and 968 seems to be supply/scarcity and thus price. There are very few 968's on the road, CS prices are going silly, Sports are starting to follow suit, even the slightly derided coupe (especially tip) is following slowly upward in value- and if you are ever lucky enough to get hands on a 968 turbo or turbo S - it's an investment purchase! It seems a few 944's are also starting to get such recognition, but many are not so prices remain lower than perhaps they should be.
OLD_ian
New member
pauljmcnulty
Active member
The only comparable 944 to a standard 968 is the S2 it's based on. There are around three times the number of S2s still registered, compared to the 968, so there is an argument they have a greater value because of the rarity.
I wonder if you need to factor spares in to that, though? The bridge spoiler alone costs the price of a 944 Lux with an MOT, the unique 968 panels are rare compared to the S2 that shares parts with the turbo. Will the 968-unique parts become so expensive that the S2 is the better option?
pauljmcnulty
Active member
I think most of us see the progression of the standard road models. 924 introduced the format, 944 added a bit of "butch", whilst the 924S gained the engine the car had been crying out for.
The series 2 944 developed it into a more mature car, added a proper cab to the range, and the Turbo and 16V families divided in to two clear lines with different characters.
The 968 morely followed one of those lines, arguably developing it to perfection in the CS and sport.
The 968 Tip offered a proper auto option for the first time.
Strange they never developed the turbos further, but there is always the "it would have thrashed the 911" argument there. I tihnk it's because they were bought by the wrong type of person. []
I think there are very close links between a 924 and a series one 944, as there are between an S2 and a standard 968. To me, the big leap is the series 2 cars: there's a huge gulf between a turbo or S2 and a 924 2.0: far greater than that between a late 944 and a 968.
Neil Haughey
New member
ORIGINAL: TTM
Err not really... You can convert an oval dash 944 into a 968 with body panels, but it's going to be a hell of a lot more work to convert a 924 into an oval dash 944 as there are lots of differences in the shells.
Please don't perpetuate nonsense like this, if you have ever actually seen a 968 close in the flesh or owned one you would know this is complete and utter nonsense.
Posts made and opinions expressed are those of the individual forum members
Use of the Forum is subject to the Terms and Conditions
Disclaimer
The opinions expressed on this site are not necessarily those of the Club, who shall have no liability in respect of them or the accuracy of the content. The Club assumes no responsibility for any effects arising from errors or omissions.
Porsche Club Great Britain gives no warranties, guarantees or assurances and makes no representations or recommendations regarding any goods or services advertised on this site. It is the responsibility of visitors to satisfy themselves that goods and/or services supplied by any advertiser are bona fide and in no instance can the Porsche Club Great Britain be held responsible.
When responding to advertisements please ensure that you satisfy yourself of any applicable call charges on numbers not prefixed by usual "landline" STD Codes. Information can be obtained from the operator or the white pages. Before giving out ANY information regarding cars, or any other items for sale, please satisfy yourself that any potential purchaser is bona fide.
Directors of the Board of Porsche Club GB, Club Office Staff, Register Secretaries and Regional Organisers are often requested by Club members to provide information on matters connected with their cars and other matters referred to in the Club Rules. Such information, advice and assistance provided by such persons is given in good faith and is based on the personal experience and knowledge of the individual concerned.
Neither Porsche Club GB, nor any of the aforementioned, shall be under any liability in respect of any such information, advice or assistance given to members. Members are advised to consult qualified specialists for information, advice and assistance on matters connected with their cars at all times.