The first thing to realise is that the car is a turbo.
This might sound obvious, but a turbo car is not a normally aspirated car with more power.
I have attached the torque curve for the 996TT. I believe the torque curve is for full throttle, and it does not feel to me like you get 300Nm at 1100 rpm.
You do not get monster torque from tickover, only a 8 litre diesel engine will do that.
You need to get to 2500 rpm, then it really picks up. You get a push in the back that the normally aspirated cars just can't match, since you 50%+ more torque at 3000rpm.
3000 to 5500 is where you do most of the work. There is not much point going beyond 6000, since changing up will resume the acceleration better.
This is quite different from the normally aspirated cars where you want to be above 4500 for real performance and going up to 7000 is good (or more if you have a GT3).
In real world driving away from the track, the mid range is where you are more likely to be. You may be able to keep the revs up on the track, but on the road it is a different matter. The turbo is designed for road use first (although it is pretty good on a track).
From the Porsche turbo race cars you will see that the rev limits are quite low on them also, so this is in keeping with their general philosophy which is to get as much torque as possible as early as possible. It aids drive out of corners.
In terms of sharpness, then you can notice the on/off boost behaviour. The throttle responds about the same if you disconnected the turbos, it is just that when the turbos blow you get a lot more, so you feel as if is a little slower. The engine is rev happy, sharing design and most innards with the GT3 and GT2. When changing down, you can blip the throttle very nicely, although it takes some practice.
Porsche try to reduce lag, since if you lift off it will open a bypass valve to keep the turbos spinning. Then if you plant the throttle again, the boost is instantly there. Changing up quickly with only a brief lift and then full application of power, will show that the boost (on the dashboard if you can look) is there straight away. Similarly, if you lift off fractionally and then reapply the power it will not show any lag. Lift for 1 sec or more, and the turbos will have slowed down.
The headers are very short, so the turbos are as close to the exhaust from the cylinders as possible, so the response and spool up time is very short.
Turbo cars have non-linear power delivery. It often feels as if you need to lift off the accelerator as you accelerate, in order to keep a constant acceleration. The 996 is not too bad for this, since the torque is quite flat, and the power line quite straight (other turbo cars show this more).
I like the power delivery, the shove in the back, and the real world usability.
But the experience is quite different. Many people do not like it. I am the the other way round, I have tried the normally aspirated cars, thinking the smoother power delivery, better throttle response, more controllability was the way to go, as all the conventional wisdom suggests. I used to have a 996C4S, but it did not do it for me. Perhaps it was 5 years with a different turbo before, that set me on this course.
Any drawbacks?
The car is heavier, you have the stonger gearbox, heavier crankcase, two intercoolers, two turbos, additional water cooling, additional radiator, more air ducting, and more oil. Most of this extra weight also sits behind the rear wheels, plus the engine sits 40+ mm further back. So the weight balance is tipped further in favour of the rear wheels.
The exhaust note is quieter. The pulses of gas which make the noise on a normally aspirated car are smoothed by the turbos, so the silencer is smaller and the sounds are lower.
There is some lag, no matter what you do. Porsche claim is like driving a car with a bigger engine, but a bigger normally aspirated engine has the torque available instantly.
If you do not like using the torque, but prefer to rev right to the limit in every gear, using the top end power and feeling fully connected to the engine at the top end, then it is not the same feeling having a turbo.
The engine has a lower rev limit than Porsche normally aspirated units, so you can't hear it sing at so high a pitch.
Tyre wear can be higher if you use the grunt all the time, as can fuel consumption.
Your driving licence is at risk unless you exercise a good deal of restraint.
Anyway, all this is meaningless. You have to try it to see whether you like it.
However, it takes miles of driving to really get the most out of it.
You also need to be smoother, so slow into the corner, get the car set with constant throttle, the accelerate out of the corner (using the rear weight bias) before nailing it as the wheels straighten. Brake too late, start playing with the throttle too much, be in the wrong gear, and it all starts feeling a bit messy. Same as any 911, but perhaps a little more so.
The balance is superb and you can slide the rear wheels slightly, plus you can get the rears to spin as well (not too much), without the traction control or PSM coming in. That's when you know you have got it right.