Menu toggle

Chesil/Tygan

I can sense a bit of tension here between some of the contributors so why dont you take a look at the discription and photos of e bay item:- 230259478036. I hope this will keep both the VW and Porsche Camps Happy !

Has anyone taken a look at this e bay item yet 230259478036? There are now nine (YES 9 ) bids on this beauty - I just had another look at the main picture. Dont be to dissapointed if you miss this one - he has another in the making. See main picture in the back ground to the right. Can you spot the next one in Red this time?


Enjoy your cars whatever they are!
 
ORIGINAL: kenparker

Having taken an interest in this post I have always been open to both real cars and replica cars. Both can be as good as each other for what you want to get out of them. Some are even better than the orginals. This is due to the improved design of parts and the availablity.

Exactly...........[:)]
 
ORIGINAL: JCB..

I think Brian meant Anne, Helen but he wouldn't last five minutes with you either! [;)]
I know he did but i just couldn't resist replying with that answer ..




well i thought it was funny..

[:-]umm, maybe i should have used real fur for my wolf's clothing

 
ORIGINAL: kenparker
What I will say is I noted that there was a 356 Speedster Replica in the line up of classic Porsches at a recent early event with this very club. I just wounder who noticed a very nice kit, well made and the detail was spot on. I am sure it's a joy to drive.

I actually dont disagree with most of your reply Helen, apart mainly from the fact that, NO kitcars should not be on a display at a Porsche Show. Take them to a kitcar show if you want appreciation for them.

Ken, you were not alone in wondering why it was there. Plenty of people mentioned that Kitcar should not have been there, in silly outlaw clothing at that.
Thats why they are not allowed, because they are the very people who break rules deliberately, when rules are there for a reason.
How would you feel having worked hard all your life to buy your dream Speedster, only to find some muppet decides to crash your display and park his plastic fantastic right next to you.
People did'nt drive many hours to get there only to have a kitcar park next to them :rolleyes:

I very much hope there ARE complaints about it.

I am not a snob but I just appreciate people who make an effort to keep the stock scene alive and organise such displays off their own back in their own time for other people's enjoyment.
There are very few stock displays, and some idiot feels fit to spoil it.
People who love stock dont want to park with kitcars in a display. Yet people with kitcars seem to want to crash their display.
Thats selfishness on their part, not snobbery on mine.
[:)]
 
good grief..
there is no hope for you. . i couldn't give a dam if someone parked their 356 or 911 kit car (and yes, they are made) right next to my real ones, infact i would be flattered. and have a bit of a laugh with them. i certainly wouldn't be threatened by them.

life is far too short to be so worried about such a little thing..

if you have a real speedster then enjoy it and stop fretting that somone else is getting as much pleasure out of a replica of your car for a fraction of the cost.
i think your real problem is that lesser mortals can't tell the diffrence. thats your problem and not mine.. i am quite Happy with my fibreglass copy.

 
..just for the record there is NO suggestion that replicas should be at shows along side the original Porsches.. the usual course is that they have their own display area within the show. Plus a few related trade stands as well in the traders area.

this has not only worked well at other shows it has infact been benificial to both parties

Walton Hall 2005
n757597829_599262_4867.jpg

 
ORIGINAL: mrsherbie

ORIGINAL: kenparker
What I will say is I noted that there was a 356 Speedster Replica in the line up of classic Porsches at a recent early event with this very club. I just wounder who noticed a very nice kit, well made and the detail was spot on. I am sure it's a joy to drive.

I actually dont disagree with most of your reply Helen, apart mainly from the fact that, NO kitcars should not be on a display at a Porsche Show. Take them to a kitcar show if you want appreciation for them.

Ken, you were not alone in wondering why it was there. Plenty of people mentioned that Kitcar should not have been there, in silly outlaw clothing at that.
Thats why they are not allowed, because they are the very people who break rules deliberately, when rules are there for a reason.
How would you feel having worked hard all your life to buy your dream Speedster, only to find some muppet decides to crash your display and park his plastic fantastic right next to you.
People did'nt drive many hours to get there only to have a kitcar park next to them :rolleyes:

I very much hope there ARE complaints about it.

I am not a snob but I just appreciate people who make an effort to keep the stock scene alive and organise such displays off their own back in their own time for other people's enjoyment.
There are very few stock displays, and some idiot feels fit to spoil it.
People who love stock dont want to park with kitcars in a display. Yet people with kitcars seem to want to crash their display.
Thats selfishness on their part, not snobbery on mine.
[:)]

Anne,

If you can take a timeout from your soapbox and read Ken's post what he said was:

What I will say is I noted that there was a 356 Speedster Replica in the line up of classic Porsches at a recent early event with this very club. I just wonder who noticed a very nice kit, well made and the detail was spot on. I am sure it's a joy to drive.

Which the rest of the world interprets as "That nice".

It also means that someone, presumably a PCGB club member, had the audacity to park the spawn of Satan in a Porsche line-up at a Porsche Club GB event. Then if that wasn't bad enough another PCGB member came along and thought it well made and well detailed. Things are really going to the dogs, there was even a display of motorcycles at Eynsham the other year. Do you know the people that ride those things wear leather trousers? (Sorry PK [;)]).

I do actually have a major problem with your claim of not being a snob.

snob
noun [C] MAINLY DISAPPROVING
a person who respects and likes only people who are of a high social class, and/or a person who has extremely high standards who is not satisfied by the things that ordinary people like:

This might be OTT...

xenophobia
noun
extreme dislike or fear of foreigners, their customs, their religions, etc.
 
JCB, as your the owner of a poor mans 911 substitute.. how dare you wonder UP into the 356 forum area and have the nerve to vent an opinion

[;)][:D][:D][:D]
Said with tongue firmly wedged in my cheek

 
and before anyone shouts. i think JCB knows i'm joking..

i love the Boxster.. and to prove it heres me having some fun with mine (complete with plastic body kit[;)][:D])
1446039631_135ba74fc1.jpg
1446898234_a83d874b39.jpg

for me Porsches are for driving not just to looking pretty at shows
 

ORIGINAL: Helen Goff

..just for the record there is NO suggestion that replicas should be at shows along side  the original Porsches.. the usual course is that they have their own display  area within the show.

this has not only worked well at other shows it has infact been benificial  to both parties

They are not Porsches so should not be anywhere within the show.

Having kitcars at a Porsche show does not benefit owners of real Porsches in any way at all.
Pass me a match.

[:)]

 
[:D] oh I just found these faces and I can use them

Well i have never been involved with a typing face off.. [:D]

I think I have made my corner clear.. The kit I saw looked well made and well detailed. Personaly don't care if they parked next to my car. The person has taken alot of time to detail the car to the orginal. I hope they enjoy it.. I certainly would.

Now I understand why the 912 owner I met up with said to me to enjoy the club but watch out. Get what you can from it and ignor the rest. He was right!! how much was it to join this cat claw club?

Like I said other clubs have replica's and are very much part of the club. If this club do not like it then fine. There will be others that will. I will be at Classic Le Mans in a few weeks and I will see countless replica's and the detail will be a joy to see and the owners I am sure will enjoy telling me how much time and effort they took to get the car right.. many will be on the race track next to orginals.

So what about the 904 replica's. What an amazing car, 911 running gear and an almost total match to the orginal. I would be tempted my self if my pension wasn't doing so bad. [:D]
 
ORIGINAL: Helen Goff

and before anyone shouts. i think JCB knows i'm joking..

i love the Boxster.. and to prove it heres me having some fun with mine (complete with plastic body kit[;)][:D])
1446039631_135ba74fc1.jpg
1446898234_a83d874b39.jpg

for me Porsches are for driving not just to looking pretty at shows

[:D] That's why I bought mine! Yeah Baby!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
 
ORIGINAL: Helen Goff

..just for the record there is NO suggestion that replicas should be at shows along side the original Porsches.. the usual course is that they have their own display area within the show.

this has not only worked well at other shows it has infact been benificial to both parties

Walton Hall 2005
n757597829_599262_4867.jpg


I've studied this photo long and hard....

and I do believe the fake is the ones in Red..... [;)]

I'll get my coat..

garyw
 
ORIGINAL: garyw

ORIGINAL: Helen Goff

..just for the record there is NO suggestion that replicas should be at shows along side the original Porsches.. the usual course is that they have their own display area within the show.

this has not only worked well at other shows it has infact been benificial to both parties

Walton Hall 2005
n757597829_599262_4867.jpg


I've studied this photo long and hard....

and I do believe the fake is the ones in Red..... [;)]

I'll get my coat..

garyw

correct that ones definatly molded around a dodgy chassis & floorpan, and i think looks could be improved with some new light weight body panels. but on the whole shes not a bad runner considering her age [;)][:D]
 
I find it amusing that a few people who dont seem to understand why rules are created to give form to any car show, and then stamp their feet and resort to personal insult and make incorrect assumptions & statements just because they are wrong. ( But dont like it)

My views do not represent any club or person other than my own.

I joined POCGB only recently last year interested to meet other people and discover more about other cars like our own and attend one or two meets each year where we can look at genuine real and correct cars of all models. ( Oh and the magazine is superb!)
I am also in the Historic VW Club GB for the same reasons. Stock cars are the minority in the VW scene, but fortunately in the Porsche scene, the prices seem to be keeping the modifiers out for a bit longer.
We see many Porschealike kitcars each year on 70's floorpans/reg's at both local carshows and VW shows. And there is certainly nothing wrong with them in their own right for what they are, 'a kitcar that looks a bit like a Porsche'.

BUT it is a VERY refreshing change JUST ONCE A YEAR not to have to walk round them.
Just hundreds of correct and rare Porsches in a rainbow of correct & original factory colours! [:)][:)]



 

Posts made and opinions expressed are those of the individual forum members

Use of the Forum is subject to the Terms and Conditions

Disclaimer

The opinions expressed on this site are not necessarily those of the Club, who shall have no liability in respect of them or the accuracy of the content. The Club assumes no responsibility for any effects arising from errors or omissions.

Porsche Club Great Britain gives no warranties, guarantees or assurances and makes no representations or recommendations regarding any goods or services advertised on this site. It is the responsibility of visitors to satisfy themselves that goods and/or services supplied by any advertiser are bona fide and in no instance can the Porsche Club Great Britain be held responsible.

When responding to advertisements please ensure that you satisfy yourself of any applicable call charges on numbers not prefixed by usual "landline" STD Codes. Information can be obtained from the operator or the white pages. Before giving out ANY information regarding cars, or any other items for sale, please satisfy yourself that any potential purchaser is bona fide.

Directors of the Board of Porsche Club GB, Club Office Staff, Register Secretaries and Regional Organisers are often requested by Club members to provide information on matters connected with their cars and other matters referred to in the Club Rules. Such information, advice and assistance provided by such persons is given in good faith and is based on the personal experience and knowledge of the individual concerned.

Neither Porsche Club GB, nor any of the aforementioned, shall be under any liability in respect of any such information, advice or assistance given to members. Members are advised to consult qualified specialists for information, advice and assistance on matters connected with their cars at all times.

Back
Top