Menu toggle

Are Spyders Becoming Extinct At OPCs!

ORIGINAL: flat6 [:D] please post the pic you'd like me to use. Otherwise I might fail you again[:)]
This one suits the spirit of the car better than a traffic jam. Happy memories too [:D]
DSC_0034_zpsa0c8954d.jpg
 
ORIGINAL: MrDemon Had mine close to 2 years, was a Xmas present. I.ll prob change the R next March, buts that's more a miles, tax thing not because I want to.
So fast forward to March 2014 and what would be the natural replacement for a "R"?
 
ORIGINAL: daro911
ORIGINAL: MrDemon Had mine close to 2 years, was a Xmas present. I.ll prob change the R next March, buts that's more a miles, tax thing not because I want to.
So fast forward to March 2014 and what would be the natural replacement for a "R"?
The only thing I may consider if they're as good as people say is a GT3, although I have never driven one I would have to have a good try 1st
 
ORIGINAL: daro911
ORIGINAL: MrDemon Had mine close to 2 years, was a Xmas present. I.ll prob change the R next March, buts that's more a miles, tax thing not because I want to.
So fast forward to March 2014 and what would be the natural replacement for a "R"?
Aston n420, R8, 911 turbo,GTR, to name a few. Really fancy a Aston 4.7 with sports options for a year, a n420 if I can find one. Def not a GT3 for daily use.
 
ORIGINAL: MrDemon
ORIGINAL: daro911
ORIGINAL: MrDemon Had mine close to 2 years, was a Xmas present. I.ll prob change the R next March, buts that's more a miles, tax thing not because I want to.
So fast forward to March 2014 and what would be the natural replacement for a "R"?
Aston n420, R8, 911 turbo,GTR, to name a few. Really fancy a Aston 4.7 with sports options for a year, a n420 if I can find one. Def not a GT3 for daily use.
My brother had a N400 Vantage Volante which was one sweet sounding machine so I borrowed a manual Volante from the local Aston dealer for a weekend. Picked it up Saturday at 10.00am and had to drop it back by 5.00 the next day. 4 Hours later with very few miles but many gallons of fuel consumed I returned the car to the dealer. It was heavy, it felt enormous, it drank fuel like something from the 1970's would have done and fun factor wise it was just not happening for me. I deliberately drove it on regular rat runs I did in my then Boxster S it was seriously hard work. Heavy clutch heavy slow truck like gearbox and all the time a lot of metal to worry about. Apart from the soundtrack the car didn't tick a single box for me and the servicing costs are in a different area code to a Porsche[:D] After your obsession for light weights I would suggest borrowing an Aston for 48 hours and see if you can adjust to a heavy weight BIG drinker ... I couldn't
7349452b77dea39deba003e3235e74e7.JPG
 
ORIGINAL: MrDemon
ORIGINAL: daro911
ORIGINAL: MrDemon Had mine close to 2 years, was a Xmas present. I.ll prob change the R next March, buts that's more a miles, tax thing not because I want to.
So fast forward to March 2014 and what would be the natural replacement for a "R"?
Aston n420, R8, 911 turbo,GTR, to name a few. Really fancy a Aston 4.7 with sports options for a year, a n420 if I can find one. Def not a GT3 for daily use.
MrD the difference between you and I is that I don't drive my car on a daily commute or for work. It is for pleasure only, therefore practicality is not a problem. (Other than the Lotus which I had to remove the roof to get out [:-] )
 
One of the differences between you and MrD is that you don't use your car as a daily driver [;)] I can see you in a GT3 Andy. Like your new profile pic, something I recognise on there!
 
The Gt3 thing is personal issue for me that's all, for me no good to do 12k miles in every year as a daily run about. And no good on the roads where I live. Mine did my head in. A nice 2nd car , but I have my Spyder as a 2nd car so no good having two cars like that. I spent a day with Aston and drove them all through out the day. 4.3 , 4.7 , 4.7 with sport pack and the vantage S Ended up with the M3 competition but soon sold that off in 3 months for my R. I must say the 4.7 with sport pack is night and day better than the older n400 and the 4.3 cars. The N420 being the best of the lot, nice body kit, amazing sports exhaust and with the buckets a great place to sit. The feel good factor of driving a Aston just feels nice, yes petrol and car tax is a issue, but that n420 noise is wonderful. I see the new ltd ed is a vantage S in manual, but £90k lol. A turbo car for daily use fits the bill better, usable performance In a turbo as it cuts in so fast and no need to rev it out. Gt3 only comes to life above 6k and with the long gearing it's not possible to rev the car out in 3rd on B roads. It' A good euro track day hack, no good in the UK where I live where 85mph is the exciting B road speed. 85mph puts a GT3 in no mans land down in low revs in 3rd gear ,very fustrating. It's not easy finding a exciting daily hack which is ok on fuel and does not drop like a stone in value if you put another 15k miles on it. Was always a hot hatch man when I had the Lotus and nobles as my weekend cars, my Clio trophy was a right hoot. I'll see what gen 2 911 turbos are like next year would quite fancy one of those.
 
mn
ORIGINAL: MrDemon Gt3 only comes to life above 6k and with the long gearing it's not possible to rev the car out in 3rd on B roads. It' A good euro track day hack, no good in the UK where I live where 85mph is the exciting B road speed. 85mph puts a GT3 in no mans land down in low revs in 3rd gear ,very fustrating.
Interesting as I like my cars to be a lot of fun low down the rev range and I can't stress how disappointed I recently was trying out a 20k mile Porsche Cars GB 997 Gen 2 GT3 demo car because my hours drive was all below 4500 rpm and down there not only was it feeling very mundane it sounded it too[&o] I was later told had I been up the rev range it would have been a different story which is fair enough but not how I like to drive I think a Gen 2 Turbo would be a far better bet as a daily driver on UK roads My daily driver a Mini Cooper S is the perfect A-B town car for me with plenty of punch without ever having to rev the nuts off it and still manages 30mpg around town I have read the later AMV are vastly improved over the N400's era but the running costs and frequest servcing still remain unchanged and after a Porsche that is all a little old school in this day and age of 2 year intervals
 
Looks a good replacement for any Cayman R owners [;)] http://www.autocar.co.uk/car-review/lotus/exige/first-drives/lotus-exige-v6-cup-first-drive-review
 
ORIGINAL: daro911 Looks a good replacement for any Cayman R owners [;)] http://www.autocar.co.uk/car-review/lotus/exige/first-drives/lotus-exige-v6-cup-first-drive-review
They just don't really have the presence of a Porsche and not a bargain at 63k IMO
 
ORIGINAL: Andy Fagan
ORIGINAL: daro911 Looks a good replacement for any Cayman R owners [;)] [link=http://www.autocar.co.uk/car-review/lotus/exige/first-drives/lotus-exige-v6-cup-first-drive-review]http://www.autocar.co.uk/car-review/lotus/exige/first-drives/lotus-exige-v6-cup-first-drive-review[/link]
They just don't really have the presence of a Porsche and not a bargain at 63k IMO
Agreed but probably excellent value used[;)]
 
ORIGINAL: daro911 mn
ORIGINAL: MrDemon Gt3 only comes to life above 6k and with the long gearing it's not possible to rev the car out in 3rd on B roads. It' A good euro track day hack, no good in the UK where I live where 85mph is the exciting B road speed. 85mph puts a GT3 in no mans land down in low revs in 3rd gear ,very fustrating.
Interesting as I like my cars to be a lot of fun low down the rev range and I can't stress how disappointed I recently was trying out a 20k mile Porsche Cars GB 997 Gen 2 GT3 demo car  because my hours drive was all below 4500 rpm and down there not only was it feeling very mundane it sounded it too[&o]  I was later told had I been up the rev range it would have been a different story which is fair enough but not how I like to drive   I think a Gen 2 Turbo would be a far better bet as a daily driver on UK roads My daily driver a Mini Cooper S is the perfect A-B town car for me with plenty of punch without ever having to rev the nuts off it and still manages 30mpg around town  I have read the later AMV are vastly improved over the N400's era but the running costs and frequest servcing still remain unchanged and after a Porsche that is all a little old school in this day and age of 2 year intervals
I also have a Mini Cooper S, great fun. Thinking of swapping that to the fiesta ST. I let the gf use it , but I use it to go shopping and short 2 mile trips. And the odd long business trip to save petrol and keep the miles off the R a bit. Also does the tip run and any shit jobs :).
 
You mention you have been happy with hot hatches for the everyday motor. I was very pleased with my Megane RS its a little basic inside but as a drivers car absolutely brilliant and for everyday in my opinion better even than the Focus RS that followed it. If you have not tried one take a test drive you won't be disappointed. Geoff
 
ORIGINAL: geoff lane You mention you have been happy with hot hatches for the everyday motor. I was very pleased with my Megane RS its a little basic inside but as a drivers car absolutely brilliant and for everyday in my opinion better even than the Focus RS that followed it. If you have not tried one take a test drive you won't be disappointed. Geoff
What is build quality like these days[&o] [link=http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u5BhaxIs8Co]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u5BhaxIs8Co[/link] [link=http://www.autocar.co.uk/car-review/renault/megane/first-drives/renaultsport-megane-250]http://www.autocar.co.uk/car-review/renault/megane/first-drives/renaultsport-megane-250[/link]
 
It,s the cost, they drop like a stone and 2nd hand they are tatty and fall apart. Had 4 renaults a whole lot of fun but you need to sell before 30k miles lol A ford focus RS is solid value, would be my choice with a 400bhp upgrade. Again it was either the RS or the m3, I choose wrong and should have had the RS, But the m3 caused me to buy the R so not all bad. Smaller cars the Clio 200 is king, but again not great with miles on them.
 
I put 25000 miles on my Megane RS in a year it was a demonstrator 6 months old with 4000 miles on it when I bought it, paid £23K for it and traded it against the Focus RS for £17K. Nothing fell off it, it had 1 service at just over £100 and a pair of front tyres which I thought was more than acceptable. The build quality was ok not up to Porsche standards, it didn't rattle but the quality of the interior lets it down however as a driving machine it was superb on both main roads and B roads. The Focus was 18months old and cost me £24k but only had 2000 miles on it, I used it for 10months and put 22000 miles on it and sold it for £18750 and again 1 service and a full set of tyres although I had swoped them front to back as it does wear front tyres and shoulders them. As an everyday car on main roads its great and the noise is something you never tire of hearing, the pops and bangs don't let you forget your driving a performance car but on British B roads as an everyday car it is just a bit to hardcore, it attracted far more attention than the Megane but the wife thought it was chavvy so it went and was replaced with the current everyday car a 330D M Sport which is a bit sensible !! Just my opinion. Geoff
 
Powerful arguments for BMW as daily driver. Have put over 50000 miles on mine now - still on original brakes/ battery and 100% fault free with room in the back for my 2 little ones - although son and heir is as tall as me now at 15! I don't do the annual mileage that some of you boys do and have had it 4 1/2 years now which is unprecedented for me.
 
ORIGINAL: Andy Fagan
ORIGINAL: daro911 So fast forward to March 2014 and what would be the natural replacement for a "R"?
The only thing I may consider if they're as good as people say is a GT3, although I have never driven one I would have to have a good try 1st
2011_porsche_911_gt3_and_2012_porsche_cayman_r_304_2_cd_gallery_zoomed.jpg
 
And yes, a repeat video[8D] http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zcPh4XaU1H0 http://www.caranddriver.com/features/the-mid-vs-rear-engine-debate-porsche-cayman-r-vs-911-gt3-feature
 

Posts made and opinions expressed are those of the individual forum members

Use of the Forum is subject to the Terms and Conditions

Disclaimer

The opinions expressed on this site are not necessarily those of the Club, who shall have no liability in respect of them or the accuracy of the content. The Club assumes no responsibility for any effects arising from errors or omissions.

Porsche Club Great Britain gives no warranties, guarantees or assurances and makes no representations or recommendations regarding any goods or services advertised on this site. It is the responsibility of visitors to satisfy themselves that goods and/or services supplied by any advertiser are bona fide and in no instance can the Porsche Club Great Britain be held responsible.

When responding to advertisements please ensure that you satisfy yourself of any applicable call charges on numbers not prefixed by usual "landline" STD Codes. Information can be obtained from the operator or the white pages. Before giving out ANY information regarding cars, or any other items for sale, please satisfy yourself that any potential purchaser is bona fide.

Directors of the Board of Porsche Club GB, Club Office Staff, Register Secretaries and Regional Organisers are often requested by Club members to provide information on matters connected with their cars and other matters referred to in the Club Rules. Such information, advice and assistance provided by such persons is given in good faith and is based on the personal experience and knowledge of the individual concerned.

Neither Porsche Club GB, nor any of the aforementioned, shall be under any liability in respect of any such information, advice or assistance given to members. Members are advised to consult qualified specialists for information, advice and assistance on matters connected with their cars at all times.

Back
Top